Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutHO95-06 Anderson REGULAR PLANNING COMMISSION AGENDA MONDAY, SEPTEMBER 25, 1995 7:00 p.m. Call Meeting to Order Roll Call Review Minutes of Previous Meeting HEARINGS: 1. Geri Anderson - Home Occupation Request - 16575 Dutch Avenue, applicant requests approval to operate a picture framing business. 2. Judy Coursolle - Home Occupation Request - 4656 Pleasant St., applicant requests approval to operate a limousine service. 3. Jerry Halliday - Request for Variance - 16604 Inguadona Beach Cir., applicant requests the following: a 29 foot variance to permit a lakeshore setback of 46 feet instead of the required 75 feet; a 5 foot variance to permit a front yard setback of 20 feet instead of the required 25 feet; and a 5 foot variance to permit a side yard on the South of 5 feet instead of the required 1 0 feet. 4. Vaughn and Henriette Lemke - Request for Variance - 14472 Shady Beach Trail, applicant requests the following variances: a 26 foot variance to permit a lakeshore setback of 49 feet instead of the required 75 feet; and a 2.5 foot variance to permit a side yard on the East of 7.5 feet instead of the required 1 0 feet. 5. Michael and Lavon Mrugala - Request for Variance - 3874 Green Heights Trail, applicant requests the following: a 15 foot variance to permit a lakeshore setback of 60 feet instead of the required 75 feet; a 6 foot variance to permit a front yard 16200 ~5~ek Ave. S.E.. Prior Lake. MinnesotaP~372-1714 / Ph. (612) 447-4230 / Fax (612) 447-4245 AN EQUAL OPPORTIJNITY EMPLOYER 6. 7. 8. 9. AG92595.DOC setback of 19 feet on the Southwest instead of the required 25 feet; and a 8% variance to permit impervious surface coverage of 30.8% instead of 30%. Elmer Clarke - Request for Variance - 16286 Park Avenue, applicant requests the following: a 28 foot variance to permit a lakeshore setback of 47 feet instead of the required 75 feet; and a 7.9 foot variance to permit a side yard on the South of2.1 feet instead of the required 10 feet. PUBLIC HEARING - The Wilds North - Comprehensive Plan Amendment - Rezoning. PUBLIC HEARING - Consider Ordinance 95- amending Sign Ordinance 94-06. Fairview Hospital and Healthcare Services - Conditional Sign Permit, Lots 1,2 and 3, Block 2, Second Addition to Westbury Ponds. PAGE 2 PLANNING REPORT AGENDA ITEM: SUBJECT: 1 CONSIDER HOME OCCUPATION REQUEST FOR GERALDINE F. ANDERSON R. MICHAEL LEEK, ASSOCIATE PLANNER YES-X-NO SEPTEMBER 25, 1995 PRESENTER: PUBLIC HEARING: DATE: INTRODUCTION: The Planning Department has received an application for a Home Occupation Permit from Geraldine F. Anderson of 16575 Dutch Ave. SE. The applicant requests approval to operate a picture framing business. The activities of the business would be carried out in 1 room of the basement and 1 room of the upper level of the house, as well as a workshop area in the existing, attached garage. SITE CHARACTERISTICS: The subject property is developed with a single-family house with attached 3-car garage. The paved driveway appears large enough to accommodate 2-4 cars off-street. STAFF ANALYSIS: The basic premise of the City's home occupation regulations is that such occupations can be permitted which would not disrupt the surrounding neighborhood. The Ordinance at Section 6.8 provides 6 criteria by which requests for home occupation permits should be evaluated. These criteria, and staff s evaluation of the request against the criteria, are set forth below. A. The home occupation shall be carried on by a member of the family residing in the dwelling unit with not more than one employee who is not a part of the family. This occupation would be carried on solely by the applicant, who resides on the property. There would be no other employees of the occupation. B. The home occupation shall be carried on wholly within the principal or accessory structures. 16200 Eagle Creek Ave. S.E., Prior Lake, Minnesota 55372-1714 / Ph. (612) 447-4230 / Fax (612) 4h7-4245 AN EQUAL OPPORTUNITY EMPLOYER The house and garage are one structure. The occupation would be carried on wholly within the structure. The use of the workshop would not interfere with the parking capacity of the garage. C. Exterior displays or signs other than those permitted under 6.4, exterior storage of materials and exterior indication of the home occupation or variation from the residential character of the principal structure shall not be permitted. The City's Sign Ordinance, adopted in December of 1994, does not permit business signs in residential areas. D. Objectionable noise, vibration, smoke, dust, electrical disturbance, odors, heat or glare shall not be produced. The proposed occupation is not expected to produce objectionable noise, vibration, smoke, dust, electrical disturbance, odors, heat or glare. E. Articles not produced on the premises shall not be sold on the premises without a specified permit. The applicant doe not propose the sale of any items other than the framing. F. The home occupation shall not create excessive automobile traffic within the neighborhood. Because picture framing is a somewhat time intensive activity, the amount of vehicle traffic generated by people dropping off and picking up work would be limited. The applicant's driveway is sufficiently sized to handle the expected parking requirements. ALTERNATIVES: 1. Approve the home occupation permit for a picture framing business at 16575 Dutch Avenue SE. as submitted or with conditions deemed appropriate by the Planning Commission. 2. Table or continue the item for specific reasons. 3. Deny the home occupation permit because it is inconsistent with the Zoning Ordinance criteria. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends approval with the following conditions; 2 1. No off-site parking. On-site parking for a maximum of two (2) customer vehicles must be provided. 2. No exterior signs identifying the business, its products, or services. 3. No sale of products other than picture framing on the premises. 4. No employees beyond the one (1) applicant/operator. 5. The home occupation permit may not be sold, transferred or assigned. 6. The Home Occupation permit is subject to all applicable ordinance and legal requirements. Violation of any ordinance or legal requirement shall be deemed grounds for immediate revocation of the Home Occupation Permit. 7. The Home Occupation may be reviewed annually by the City. 3 RESOLUTION 9531PC A RESOLUTION GRANTING A HOME OCCUPATION PERMIT FOR GERALDINE F. ANDERSON TO OPERATE A PICTURE FRAMING BUSINESS OUT OF HER RESIDENCE AT 16575 DUTCH AVENUE SE. BE IT RESOLVED BY the Planning Commission ofthe City of Prior Lake, Minnesota; FINDINGS 1. Geraldine F. Anderson has applied for a home occupation permit under from Section 6.8 ofthe Zoning Ordinance in order to permit her to operate a picture framing business from her residence which is located in the R1- Suburban Residential zoning district at the following location, to wit; Lots 1 and 2, Spring Brook Park Second Addition, Scott County, Minnesota. 2. The Planning Commission has reviewed the application for home occupation permit as contained in Case #H095-06, and held a hearing thereon on September 25, 1995. 3. The Planning Commission has considered the effect of the proposed permit upon the health, safety, and welfare of the community, the existing and anticipated traffic conditions, light and air, danger of fire, risk to the public safety, the effect on property values in the surrounding area and the effect of the proposed variances on the Comprehensive Plan. 4. Because of the nature of the proposed home occupation and the conditions of the subject property, it is possible to use the subject property in such a way that the proposed home occupation will not result in the impairment of an adequate supply of light and air to adjacent properties, unreasonably increase congestion in the public streets, increase the danger of fire, and danger to the public safety, unreasonably diminish or impair health, safety, comfort, morals or in any other respect be contrary to the Zoning Ordinance and Comprehensive Plan. 5. The contents of Planning Case H095-06 are hereby entered into and made a part of the public record and the record of decision for this case. 16200 ~MI~~.5g~~~Prior Lake, Minnesota 55372-1714 / Ph. (612) 447-4230 / Fax (612) 447-4245 AN EQUAL OPPORTUNITY EMPLOYER CONCLUSION Based upon the Findings set forth above, the Planning Commission hereby grants and approves the requested home occupation permit with the following terms and conditions; 1. No off-site parking. On-site parking for a maximum of two (2) customer vehicles must be provided. 2. No exterior signs identifying the business, its products, or services. 3. No sale of products other than picture framing on the premises. 4. No employees beyond the one (1) applicant/operator. S. The home occupation permit may not be sold, transferred or assigned. 6. The Home Occupation permit is subject to all applicable ordinance and legal requirements. Violation of any ordinance or legal requirement shall be deemed grounds for immediate revocation of the Home Occupation Permit. 7. The Home Occupation may be reviewed annually by the City. Adopted by the Planning Commission on September 25, 1995. Thomas V oOOof, Chair ATTEST: Donald R. Rye Planning Director RESOLUTION 9531PC 2 -..'. ";"".. HO q!J- Db PIDt 2 < \.G) I D":.) I!::>. CI'lY OF PRIOR LAKE APPLICATION FOR HCJ.1E OCaJPATION PERMIT Applicant: Address: Hane Phone: Property Owner: Address: Hane Phone: Gera.fo!itle- ~. A-l1cPersof1 l(ps"7"5> 6u-fcJ1 A~ ,3,e. 411-$0'lS- L.lJN1 0: OJ Gl'rafc1;Ac- / ~<;;1<::: () u -k-/, A () e.- S. E. Lfc.f?-~IJ VS- Work Phone: 1=. .JhuI pYS,. D 1/ ~~-g7/g- Work Phone: 445-87/3 Legal Description of Site: ./...0+ S /-s. z.. 5Prl'A' f1ro4/t:.. P4r1c.. ~eclJMl. .4J"U'.f-/4Vl Propety Identification Number (PID): eR.:::,-/D/OO ItJ - 0'3i10;OOOOOO/oO " Nature and Size of Hane Occupation: ~;;*."'- fra- '"1 ilL, <' .p S-<<.: (J..VJ b fc J ".. "', ou""M'fj P'rfi '^ ___~{?~ wilrt:.ShC'p; ~ eJ4..rrPr ',(".I'><.J~ t::<.t!.4r.DntJdes .a c.tr~ tt.-...J I ...; II <.f.; 1/ tP il ot!.A'JVr -nL."s' It'.? - 9 f\I1 o-ll- us e... Present Zoning: Reasons for Request: 5+a.rTi...., b(.(s.:n~<:".$ IPtL+ a+- Y^, ho/'H-' SUBMISSION RIDUIREMENTS: (A) Canpleted application form. (B) Filing Fee. (C) Names and addresses of abutting property cwners. (D) Parcel ID (PID). CNLY COMPLETE APPLICATIONS SHALL BE REVIEWED BY 'mE PI.,ANNm3<DMMISSION. To the best of my knavledge the information presented on this form is correct. In addition, I have read Section 6.8 of the Prior Lake Zoning Ordinance which specifies requirements for Hane Occupations. I agree to prOllide information and follav the procedures as outlined in the Ordinance. ~=t.~ Applicants Signature Sutmitted this t-i'R. day of ~ 197') ~ =I ~/,~.J ) Fee Owners Signature 'mIS SPACE ro BE FILLED our BY 'mE PLANN[N;. DIREX:TOR PLANNING <DMMISSION CITY COUN:IL APPEAL APPROlID APPROlID DENIED DENIED HE:ARm; DATE HE'.AR]N; DATE Conditions: Signature of the Planning Director Date \0 o I t.r) 0'\ @ ,.1 'I ~-1-' 11 ~ ~, . l ' :::-',----,--- , 11--'-- , \--- I.~ -~ / ~ '~ Mm'! f.l!F 1\1; 11 I~~, i! If" ., ,1 .,'" ,.,~ , ~ii I 11J' ' r "..> ,W~~~~ if",'" " ' " :, "I'i ~~-II t'~! ,~ ~ / ;-- I 1 " '\ I 'JI L ,~ . .tU ,_ "'c! :'.~~:I:" ' i ""-;- il~l JJ bi: .: . '. e ~I . k ' ,,'f l' < . I' Jd.0., ' , , ' ,. , ! ,: ~.. ,. ~ ~ h - ..",\Sit.. ' ", -"'_ ' ' I ' ,I \(;.1" ,. . :p Vr-, )jJ $-0 Ii! ! ' iJi'. ' ", , ' , 'I" J~','; I ~ ~8-(tVI i'iJl' l. "u ,,~~! 't: '8U ," I I~.J . " I " ..,',. 'L,; 'u,' V / , ' " I ~',' ',' ~" .' I , ~ I ' l'f;, ,: I , , " ,~';'f>' .'~' .\rJ..m lih._ ~ f bf ',_ ~ ..' . i.-;'~J~~\'V~~ ~ ~~ ff~1~ ' 1_ :~1 :,1 ,. I 1 V I, ~', ;'" ",",,'\.,J : '~ml' l ,I,,' l ," I -; " e-': ',: ' ",,' I " , ". ! " . , ~ '3-~' ~L~,; -j] '~~i', ' '~'w'r:" ~ '"," ,: ! " t . " :.~j,~ I ~,r' .L..' , ' !Iihi. i ' lfilJ/. 1 :-,- L ~' ';','.' -~': re'- '. " ' I '?'j'\j,: It I 'Va.~' ,I>" : ,'lll'S ' ,~ , _, I I I ,,'-I~' ',' '1",T-~ ,,~',Cj, '''II ' I ~ " " l' ' I II/; II" I '" TT I" I .,' ~ ' "C}' --'-L,' ", ~ IY J"\' CJ , I~I! ..1, 1 "1 ~ C~'I~ ',: IY !.J,I il,.~II~ , 'I :-, ,1'1 : 'r~ , ,'T ,I ~-lr' I . ?\'j I L , Ii ' ,'" , r,~ - y, L;jll " . I;:.': _ 1,-_ I ' I, I,' ",[ ,; v1' lll~ !c~t-T- Ie>;. I.! : Ii >-' i --, '---" 'I ",I", 0r1 . ':'I'.',J \ ,~"', i- I , ' I ' c".., ,'. Gl l ",.1,' ) . I J~ '" . ..I':" I I,~t,+ I~' " ~. . ~.~~..! , ,,!I'~. I' ',!'" ",.,,~ II. ~', ~~I = . ""~"'" ,,,_,,,.,,.,,,. 'D,Hli ~.-'- -- ~ .'t;l rJj ~ ~ ~ ~ .~ ~~! ~ ~~I ~: rJ'J ~ u i I NOTICE OF HEARING FOR A HOME OCCUPATION PERMIT TO OPERATE A PICTURE FRAMING BUSINESS You are hereby notified that the Prior Lake Planning Commission will hold a hearing at Prior Lake Fire Station #1, located at 16776 Fish Point Road SE (Southwest of the intersection ofC.R. 21 and Fish Point Road), on: Monday, September 25,1995, at 7:00 p.m. APPLICANT: Geraldine F. Anderson 16575 Dutch Ave. S.E. Prior Lake, Minnesota 55372 SUBJECT SITE: 16575 Dutch Ave. SE., legally described as Lots 1 and 2, Spring BrookPark Second Addition REQUEST: The applicant proposes to operate a picture framing business in 1 room of the basement ofthe existing house, and a portion of the existing 3-car garage. The workshop area in the garage would not reduce the parking space in the garage. If you are interested in this issue, you should attend the hearing. The Planning Commission will accept oral and/or written comments. Questions related to this hearing should be directed to the Prior Lake Planning Department by calling 447-4230 between the hours of 8:00 a.m. and 4:30 p.m. Monday through Friday. Prior Lake Planning Commission Date Mailed: September 13, 1995 16200 ~~~reek Ave. S.E., Prior Lake, Minnesota 55372-1714 / Ph. (612) 447-4230 / Fax (612) 447-4245 AN EQUAL OPPORTUNITY EMPLOYER PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES MONDAY, SEPTEMBER 25, 1995 The September 25, 1995, Planning Commission Meeting was called to order by Commissioner V oOOof at 7 :03 p.m. Present were Commissioners Arnold, Roseth and V oOOof, Intern Commissioners Criego and Wuellner, Planning Director Don Rye, Associate Planner Michael Leek and Recording Secretary Connie Carlson. ROLL CALL: Arnold Roseth Loftus V oOOof Kuykendall Intern Commissioners: Criego Wuellner Present Present Absent (arrived at 7:18 p.m.) Present Absent Present Present REVIEW OF THE SEPTEMBER 11, 1995 MEETING MINUTES: Under Loftus Comments on page 2, change the word "form" to "from". MOTION BY ROSETH, SECOND BY ARNOLD TO APPROVE THE MINUTES AS AMENDED. Vote signified ayes by Roseth, Arnold and VoOOof. MOTION CARRIED. #1. GERALDINE ANDERSON - HOME OCCUPATION REQUEST - 16575 DUTCH AVENUE, APPLICANT REQUESTS APPROVAL TO OPERATE A PICTURE FRAMING BUSINESS. Associate Planner Michael Leek presented the information in the Staff Report dated September 25, 1995. Staff recommended approval with the following conditions: 1. No off-site parking. On-site parking for a maximum of two (2) customer vehicles must be provided. 2. No exterior signs identifYing the business, its products, or services. 3. No sale of products other than picture framing on the premises. 4. No employees beyond the one (1) applicant/operator. 5. The home occupation permit may not be sold, transferred or assigned. 6. The Home Occupation permit is subject to all applicable ordinance and legal requirements. Violation of any ordinance or legal requirement shall be deemed grounds for immediate revocation of the Home Occupation Permit. 7. The Home Occupation may be reviewed annually by the City. MN92595.DOC PAGE I .. ~ Applicant, Geraldine Anderson, 16575 Dutch Avenue SE, stated she had visited with her neighbors to let them know her intentions and they had no objections to the business. Comments from Commissioners: Arnold: .. inquired on production. (Anderson explained she would have framing and matt samples in the basement. Clients can bring in their prints and pick out matts and frames. She will advise them what looks best and tell them when to pick up the finished picture.) . delivery service once or twice a week. Roseth: · reviewed some of the conditions with applicant. Criego/Wuellner: no additional comments. V onhof: . concurs with Commissioners. MOTION BY ROSETH, SECOND BY ARNOLD TO APPROVE RESOLUTION 9531PC AS REQUESTED. V ote taken signified ayes by Roseth, Arnold and V oOOof. MOTION CARRIED. #2. JUDY COURSOLLE - HOME OCCUPATION REQUEST - 4656 PLEASANT :- ST.. APPLICANT REQUESTS APPROVAL TO OPERATE A LIMOUSINE SERVICE. Associate Planner Michael Leek presented the information in the Staff Report dated September 25, 1995. Staff recommends approval with the following conditions: 1. No off-site parking. On-site parking for a maximum of two (2) customer vehicles must be provided. 2. No exterior signs identifying the business, its products, or services. 3. No sale of products. 4. No employees beyond the one (1) applicant/operator, and one (1) driver who does not reside on the premises. 5. The home occupation permit may not be sold, transferred or assigned. 6. The Home Occupation permit is subject to all applicable ordinance and legal requirements: Violation of any ordinance or legal requirement shall be deemed grounds for immediate revocation of the Home Occupation Permit. 7. The Home Occupation may be reviewed annually by the City. 8. The Home Occupation permit is limited to the parking of one limousine on the premises. MN92595.DOC PAGE 2 AFF~DA~T OF SER~CE BY MAXL COUNTY OF SCOTT ) )ss STATE OF MINNESOTA) (J;~ ~ffT1 , ;f the' City of Prior "ake, County of Scott(~n the Stat~of Minpesota, being duly sworn, says that on the .? day of ~f.nDr, 1995, ~~e _ served the ~ attached list of persons to h ve interest in the~ ~ ~ , by mailing to them a copy thereof, enclosed in an envelope, postage prepaid, and be depositing same in the post office at Prior Lake, Minnesota, the last known address of the par;ies. Subscribed and sworn to me this day of , 1995. NOTARY PUBLIC MFMt. RECEIPT No 26262 DATE _y~~ -?) 1995'" CITY 0 F PRIOR LAKE 4629 DAKOTA STREET S.E., PRIOR LAKE. MN 55372 Recei ved of .4..bV'~~./ ~ whose address and/or legal description is l~-f~ ~~;t;L~/A:::. ~ ~ the sum of for the purpos 0 Z e~~~ dollars ~b~ Reference Invoice No. od' $ 5u. f~M~~~~ Receipt Clerk for the City of Prior Lake 1- ~ ~j; r -r-n, , , . 'I ,. ' ~ ! ' . :F . ' , I . ',-- . +c i/(> ~~l[ " ---ld ,-- T ~ ~ ,H\~ ! ~ ~:, 't ~ l iiJ> ' I '.,; I I,e '~ ] ,'" '," I.' f------'-= I' , I I I ~+-~' ~ ,r-- ~ '- f '" .1' ~__1"ili -' , ~~, ~! ,1 KJJ ",', I 11!1' rl~ ;<i:J'W---'~lil~I' : , ' _~ ,_ Hil-~V,II~ r ~,!8~0i" =~~-! 1 I, , .., " , " ,. _nn i. ~ 01-.' 4' C.J; I I, I 17.'! i '" '-1' f-;-hl :rJl' ~!~~t ,. I ., i 1~1 ~ I ' ,~fr;.~ h,.'; I ,,-~rf . r~'""':0i .' l):~t,+- i ' i ~ I A1!' 'I' L ~lP='~ ~l .. r L .......~ ; ".,...,."..,.,...., ' t' ~/.! ..,.~..~...,~ ,{~'! -.......l ~ , ~ ~ , " . ,_!-, -,-..---] I I~~ - ,'~ I ~ n_~ },l' , 1_' . 'V ""i ~ db " 6 ", .1 l~, " 'i ' '<,} '. "SPliBW"" , . r ~ ,1\ ., , G i , , , j~ I, ~'~ ~. I I ~ l' ~~. i ~ ~ I' I . ---.c. I~ I I __~. .1 i , IT::>::: " ~ HI '" III ~ f..'--.:LJ'P'I: - '~ :' ~!! 11 t ".i ~l ,j' '~I \ l!' 1: .,~': :_~~, .)' - .. i ~}-- 'p(p , IT ,~::;;\. , / < :D' ~ II ~ ~ ~ : , \ ~ l_ 'o. , =, ii t · i LJI I~ ~ t; ~it- U:1 !5~1 ~ ~!l 1::. I 6 i:::: Th ~~t~'dl.-,c.I~'"'''''l'''''':IT''' ~~~l-- 1 .' ~,,!~8 i' ,'fl',r , ? ,~..!/ 'i'';::'' ~_ ,!;jf' ~ I r' I~ ~ ~ ~ 1;00 l~~i l~ ,,; " -.L ' -- _" . '~I ' ~,Hi ! ,I i~/~r"": , II') 'G~: \1':jlI'D _I .' llL~', \ ~ ~ ,_ ,r II ,,~h.." ~/ , ": "II~[--i\,- ;' / > ~ ,l ~ 'iif--~' ' , ) ~ ".J" l l.) i \ I , ;,," ~ __ I ih. ~ ~~F .- i' ," ~~ -I "...!....; l''fu '<. ' I' 1 ~ "'/;/ ~'T"~' , ~I~'" 'I I ' --; p, I , ' .'~J' ~ ~. " ,", ! t::( f" --..... f'... ' ~ ,t---It' I > r. \' \~:- " I L' , .r:ii > , tN ~IITft ,3, '~\I \ ,'ill! ~ ~ ~ ~ , 'Ii> ~ ~ ~ , I : ! i I I I ------------------------------------------- I T- - - f)~-- ----~-s::;..--L:J -- -<----- - -- --------- -i~-----------u _m~____ ----- ------------- -l-I~-~'{'3__lJdcA~_.s_E.___ -n~-f!~iI4,-~~--~372------- ---I : I 1.---.,.. .~. -- - --....~---,-.- - ---------i /If)'b)At. -- j - -1lM!:-~--e~- ... nt-l::..s:-~~i.~;,:~~~=_ i -- -- j- -- ------ --- --_______ ____________ ___ __ ____u _______ I ~ .2kd- ~~ +-L~'!___ -------- - -;5T::'L--~~ .1-~~~~3~~ In_ - -----_ -------l _lP..-_~ .ss7 _ I i ! i + i un.. -- i ..' t i - j , i -1--- , I , I I i i i I - -I- i .) i ! i.- .--.---