HomeMy WebLinkAbout4D - Amend Creekside Estates
MEETING DATE:
AGENDA #:
PREP ARED BY:
REVIEWED BY:
AGENDA ITEM:
DISCUSSION:
FISCAL IMP ACT:
ALTERNATIVES:
CITY COUNCIL AGENDA REPORT
MAY 21, 2001
4D
JANE KANSIER, PLANNING COORDINATOR
DON RYE, PLANNING DIRECTOR
CONSIDER APPROVAL OF A RESOLUTION DENYING AN
AMENDMENT TO THE CREEKSIDE ESTATES PUD
CHANGING THE EXTERIOR MATERIALS FOR THE 24-
UNIT BUILDINGS
Historv: The Creekside Estates Planned Unit Development (PUD) was
approved by the City Council in December, 2000. The PUD .Plan included
102 units in three buildings (2, 24-unit senior condominium buildings and 1,
54-unit congregate care facility). The development plan called for exterior
materials on the buildings consisting of approximately 2/3 brick and glass
and 1/3 vinyl siding, as shown on the attached plans.
Freedom Development, LLC, and Eagle Creek Development, LLC, the
developers of Creekside Estates, submitted a request for a minor amendment
to the approved PUD development plan. This amendment involved
replacing the brick and vinyl siding on the 24-unit buildings with stucco.
The resulting exterior would be primarily stucco with brick used as an
accent around the entry and patio doors.
Current Circumstances: The City Council considered the proposed
amendment on May 7, 2001. The Council did not feel the change in
building materials was consistent with the character of the development as
originally approved. The Council noted the residents of the area expect the
exterior of the buildings will be brick and vinyl as previously approved by
the Council. The Brick exterior is more durable, maintenance free and long-
lived. The Council denied a resolution approving the proposed amendment
and directed staff to prepare a resolution denying the proposal.
Conclusion: The attached resolution denies the proposed amendment as
directed by the City Council.
Bud1?et Impact: There is no immediate budget impact as a result of this
request.
The City Council has two alternatives:
1:\0] files\Ol puds\creek amend\cc report2.doc Page J
16200 Eagle Creek Ave. S.E., Prior Lake, Minnesota 55372-1714 / Ph. (612) 447-4230 / Fax (612) 447-4245
AN EQUAL OPPORTUNITY EMPLOYER
...-.
I
RECOMMENDED
MOTION:
REVIEWED BY:
I. Adopt a resolution denying the proposed amendment to Creekside Estates
PUD Plan.
2. Defer consideration of this item for specific reasons.
Staff recommends alternative # 1. A motion and second as part of the
consent agenda adopting a resolution denying the proposed amendment to
the Creekside Estates UD Plan is appropriate.
1:\Olfiles\Olpuds\creek amend\cc report2.doc Page 2
5~
RESOLUTION O~
RESOLUTION DENYING A MINOR AMENDMENT TO THE CREEKSIDE ESTATES PLANNED UNIT
DEVELOPMENT TO CHANGE THE EXTERIOR BUILDING MATERIALS FOR THE 24-UNIT
BUILDINGS
JE
MOTION BY:
~1 C't
,
SECOND BY:
WHEREAS: the Prior Lake City Council considered the proposed minor amendment to the approved
development plan for the Creekside Estates on May 7,2001; and on May 21, 2001; and
WHEREAS: owners of property within the Creekside Estates PUD have been notified of the
proposed minor amendment in accordance with Section 1106.607 (2) b of the Zoning
Ordinance; and
WHEREAS: the City Council finds the proposed minor amendment to the Creekside Estates PUD
inconsistent with elements of the Comprehensive Plan and the Zoning Ordinance which
stress high quality design; and
WHEREAS: the City Council finds the minor amendment is inconsistent with the character of the
development as originally approved inasmuch as the proposed change would decrease
the cost and value of the project; and
WHEREAS: the City Council finds the minor amendment is not compatible with the stated purposes
and intent of Section 1105 Planned Unit Developments of the Zoning Ordinance which
require a higher standard of building design; and
WHEREAS: this project was approved as a Planned Unit Development which provided the City
Council with the ability to require a higher standard and the approved design was
deemed to be of the desired level of quality whereas the proposed changes are not.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT HEREBY RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF PRIOR LAKE,
MINNESOTA:
1. The recitals set forth above are incorporated herein as findings.
2. The proposed amendment to the Creekside Estates PUD Final Plan to allow exterior materials
consisting of textured cement stucco and brick as shown on Exhibit A to this resolution is hereby
denied.
1:\01 files\Ol puds\creek amend\deny res.doc
PAGE 1
16200 Eagle Creek Ave. S.E., Prior Lake, Minnesota 55372-1714 / Ph. (952) 447-4230 / Fax (952) 447-4245
AN EQUAL OPPORTUNITY EMPLOYER
I ,
Iii
Passed and adopted this 21st day of May, 2001.
YES
NO
Mader \ i Mader
Ericson , Ericson
Gundlach Gundlach
Petersen / Petersen
Zieska / \ Zieska
I
{Seal}
Frank Boyles, City Manager
1:\01 files\OI puds\creek amend\deny res.doc
"
PAGE 2
II i
RESOLUTION 01-XX
RESOLUTION DENYING A MINOR AMENDMENT TO THE CREEKSIDE ESTATES PLANNED UNIT
DEVELOPMENT TO CHANGE THE EXTERIOR BUILDING MATERIALS FOR THE 24-UNIT
BUILDINGS
MOTION BY:
SECOND BY:
WHEREAS: the Prior Lake City Council considered the proposed minor amendment to the approved
development plan for the Creekside Estates on May 7,2001; and on May 21,2001; and
WHEREAS: owners of property within the Creekside Estates PUD have been notified of the proposed
minor amendment in accordance with Section 1106.607 (2) b of the Zoning Ordinance;
and
WHEREAS: the City Council finds the minor amendment to the Creekside Estates PUD inconsistent
with certain elements of the Comprehensive Plan and the Zoning Ordinance; and
WHEREAS: the City Council finds the minor amendment is inconsistent with the character of the
development as originally approved; and
WHEREAS: the City Council finds the minor amendment is not compatible with the stated purposes
and intent of the Section 1105 Planned Unit Developments of the Zoning Ordinance.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT HEREBY RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF PRIOR LAKE,
MINNESOTA:
1. The recitals set forth above are incorporated herein as findings.
2. The proposed amendment to the Creekside Estates PUD Final Plan to allow exterior materials
consisting of textured cement stucco and brick as shown on Exhibit A to this resolution is hereby
denied.
Passed and adopted this 21 sl day of May, 2001.
YES NO
Mader Mader
Ericson Ericson
Gundlach Gundlach
Petersen Petersen
Zieska Zieska
{Seal} Frank Boyles, City Manager
1:\01 files\O 1 puds\creek amend\deny res.doc PAGE 1
16200 Eagle Creek Ave. S.E., Prior Lake, Minnesota 55372-1714 / Ph. (952) 447-4230 / Fax (952) 447-4245
AN EQUAL OPPORTUNITY EMPLOYER
I I
I, ,
'''-
~--=,
II.. .-.0-
j r_-~~~':" '
I :11:
I ]J; c,
I ~' I
I -
I <V
: ~
II 3-
, I' ,
i I
L_
IJZ()
70nljD
()~Ill
" ........ III
/i(J [\) 7\
r- ~ (J)
)> -
-i\CO
/Zlll
III -
u -\Ill
~ (, (J)
-- )-\
ZOJ>
ZZ-'
III 0 in
(J)O(J)
o
--I OJ
)>C
I
o
.z
(j)
XI
f'l
.~
Ul
iT]
o
(yJ
(-I
"
-"
C'
Cl
'1
Z
)>
I
u
c=
o
u
,-
)>
z
,-
o
-1
------l.
)'~,
::"(j
""\.1
;(1
o
<
rn
o
~ ,; r 1.'; > ~ - '- c1 IW;'I.liJ!' "/'\
c. l~
...;;". ,':;1\..}'O'o.:..[.,,"." ;;:;:, l t' ("''''::~ ~(l :l'.!
iil l!l!li ~! 11! I ill i!li :;
I;
DDI;~~D~DrnDQrnD
!HHH~PIlP
:g~Hq il!ia
~
1'!
."
.
U>
~
[!)
[j;
I
o tt I n ~-o
Ii ! IW ;
n ! II U~ ;~!m
h ~ i ~~, B~ I ~
~ ~ ~~l~'~!il
%~ii! $ - '~
~~i~ A~ii ~ iI ~e~~~i I
~~ ~ n~~ ~ ~ ~:~~~ I
ii~; ~!J!
mi!~ ~~!
;ii~S A
d
-
(~1\j" ~/W'; AlicH/iicT'S J;CI" CREEKSIDE ESTATES I
/,1 =: :, ~ :o~c;;';:::,,:~::N"::. ~~s:.:~:'': NEW 24 UI.JIT CONDO BUILDING I
I, _~="-=""". '" ...-........ ~R LAKE, MII\jNESOTA I
___ v ~__ ,_~______ =____
)>
'"C
'"C
:c
o
<
m
c
"'t1
r-
)>
Z
en
.~ /;-
" g; /;~ "11
: () rn ~
, 7' Z Z
rn 0 -I
r rn
rn rn ~
< F;;
~ < ~
6 ~
z 6 6
z z
I
I
I
I
I
I
I ~
I!
I
I
I I
I
)> I
Z I'
i'
en :.'
/;u i
rn I
Z I
0 I
rn I
F;; I
<
~ \
6 i
z I
I
r
l.
I
I
!
I
.....;}
. -."-'."-
:t .-l;;~
~
I!iiji!
~
~ (~;
~'I
i ,,:/
(I.-~ ~~I ~ RHA ARCHITECT'S INC iCREEKSIDE ESTATES . 1
i l> 0 6 ARCHI76<TS. PLANNellS, PCSICNC"" NEW 24 UNIT CONDO BUILDI~JG
'I.. .~ ..,.rarntJ'fUlUJI ,fID/'I.JlO-u.......,
I.. O~\:~,~:., ~"'~, ....~." '" ._.M..... PRIOR LAKE. MINNESOTA
DO]
uzn 70 II
r
/Unl/U nl 0
< -\
o~Ri -
(j) f\)
nl
/UN?' 0,
1~Cf) \J
::c
)>CO f\) )>
0
~Znl (j)
~ nl
'-' -\ nl )> OJ
~()~ ?J
0 C
r
ZO)> 0 "'C
ZZ-\ -
z
nOm (j)
(J)O(J)
0
-\0]
)>C
I
0
-
z
GJ
:r~
-c
x>
,-~
c')
9
~~~l:::~~ : ~l;.~ ~~ ~ L t.:~= :: -~ ~ ~,:Q~CD~ ::'l~
oi'J~U>~8' .rnU>U>~zccc~~~RRu'g2"'" C c, s:>"~S~ ~I
~Q@~~~= F~~g~~~~~zg@~~8~~~~ ~~~%. ~~g~s~ ~
.... v..... ""II n,... zz,-t'l z~ ~."z"-<z ....
r;;~~ ~/', ~Ol:~~~8~..~~~?~~~"~~~ "1! !13"~;>" ~
t:P~p~ :...;;o;I~ "'.....~~Ui~t;rii03:'""I.:J~~ C'o U:""lIC:O~" "'
~~~~~ &6~ ~~~C~8~?~.~P;~ ~ ~~;; ~E~~ ~
;:vt"C'c _lI' ........\Jlg,!co~tP,,;:J i: 0 \Jl% oz' \Jl
~zi~e ~ ~Q~~tfth?: ~ ~ ~;; ~(j~ ~
~ %....)> \Jlll'g )- ~. G. ~ ~ ~z 8
c G"l s: is "' 0 Ui G\ h ~ ~~ Z
Z [' z z ~ G ::r ~ U\5~ ...
~ ~ ~ C ~ C Zrn ~
~ a z ~
c Z
h
2J
Dul~m~D~~~DD81
;::
~
,..
2!1
~
..
U\
~
ell
a
\1\1
g~
Ii
~~~~ ~
~~~g ~~:-
~~~~ :~d
r H~~
~"'.r
"11IIu;
h~
~ .~~
>~~~
;~!l~
e
~qH~~H~~~~!
~PHq PH~'
ii . ~~~
1 :
o T r i ~ [>-0
E~5~~~~B
aUililSI
I g i ~~ ~
~ ~~~r~f.~1f.~~!fsT~~,c~~fs
" 1lI~ I :it &8N1tl1H ST PHON!" II,_U'_07l7
!:t CWUD, JlINNCSOrA rAX ,11_fJi_O'"
CREEKSIDE E5TATE5 LOT 2
NEW 24 UNIT CONDO BUILDING ~
PRIOR LAKE. MINNE50TA I
, .. '.' - .
-- _..,_._._-'-~----'._----'----- ---.---'----"----
in~~ ~~ng l!
~c~ ~~~g-
~~~ ~~~~ ~
~.Q~ ~~.Q n
~. c ~~. ~
~ ~r~ ~~~! l
~
lS.. ~:~;Q~
~. ~~~li~~
"i "i"i"i"i~
~n >
-~~
~o&
~~,~
~~
6
~O.
o ~!1
~ n i
. " 8
., I
.I~, Ii
32'~6.
t m ~ !~, k
) ~ ~( I
/;,. / 'j' i ~ (Ii -
/ /~
OJ I (Ii "' ~
h JII II II! '\/ .. ?O
_.u - 0
7' -- ., y nl .. Z
I Z -I
nl \ 0
.- [m _I ::\) nl
nl nl .-
< - Fn nl
~ <
- - < ~
0 ~
z ..... .... 0 0
=1\ z z
n_, ~- \
- - \
- \
,
~
/
- - - /
-1/ I
~u_ I I
I
J
'-
r-- - -
.... --
- -
f- f-- f--
- FV~J
I-
- J.
.... -'(
-
-
,
- f
_1\
- )
f- -!m !
f--
~ '"- .....
l- I-- I--
,.... """',
~
I I-- I-- I-
-
f
G>
~ ~ ~ \ I
,I /
L-.. I )Ii
~ _~ -E ' ;4i'/if.
~ : 1/ j.'
- L....' f
~trI- - - I-- I )/.
l'~ r 1/ I
;g ~'.I
- II
~ I ,,-..
01 "-0.1
!~(
;U
IIi
'l
\
\1-1--
32'-6"
(~I.o>)
nl
Z
CJ
nl
.-
nl
<
);>
-I I ~~f
o iW,
z ~9;g
_Ql,
\
\
)
~r
l
VJ
I I
/ :
(;i
tW
i~f
aH
[ (;~11D1m\. D.... ~ :;::::~;;~=~::~::'ll ~~;~I~~~5~~:;gO BU~~~N~
~"c...... ......". W 'H-'U-',"~ FRIOR LAKE. MINNE50TA
-rl-- r --1- -- . -
"'0
:II
o
"'0
o
CJ)
m
C
~
s::
m
z
0- C
s::
m
0- Z
-4
l~~
I'
~~~ j [ T .~18~ I~
5'.c~h _ ,.L?~!Z~n_.. ~ ~
III