HomeMy WebLinkAbout07 06 2026 PC Minutes
1
PRIOR LAKE PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES
Monday, July 6, 2026
1. Call to Order and Pledge of Allegiance:
Chair Fleming called the Prior Lake Planning Commission meeting to order at 6:01 P.M.
Commissioners present: Bryan Fleming, Sam Rook, Kate Yurko, and Shelley Schmokel.
Absent: Christian Fenstermacher, Michael Tennison, and Daniel Nicholson. Also present:
Community Development Director Casey McCabe, City Planner Jacob Skluzacek, City Planner
Paul Moretto, Assistant City Engineer Luke Schwarz, and Development Service Assistant
Sandra Peppin.
2. Approval of Agenda:
MOTION BY ROOK, SECONDED BY SCHMOKEL TO APPROVE THE MONDAY, JULY 6,
2026, PLANNING COMMISSION AGENDA.
VOTE: Ayes by Fleming, Rook, Yurko, and Schmokel.
Motion carried 4-0.
3. Approval of Meeting Minutes:
MOTION BY ROOK SECONDED BY YURKO TO APPROVE THE MONDAY, JUNE 1, 2026,
PRIOR LAKE PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES.
VOTE: Ayes by Fleming, Rook, Yurko, and Schmokel.
Motion carried 4-0.
4. Public Hearing:
A. PDEV26-000017 – 14163 Shady Beach Trl NE – Combined Preliminary and Final Plat –
Highmark Builders, on behalf of the property owner Jason Haus, is requesting approval of a
combined preliminary and final plat which will combine two (2) existing lots into one (1) lot. Both
single-family homes on these lots will be demolished and replaced with one new single-family
detached home. Additionally, they are proposing property boundary adjustments to incorporate
sections of several adjacent lots into the newly created lot. (PID’s: 259300410 & 251140024)
Planner Skluzacek: Introduced the request for a Combined Preliminary and Final Plat, pointing
out key points such as the history, physical site characteristics, and gave a staff
recommendation of approval for the requested Combined Preliminary and Final Plat of Haus
Addition subject to the conditions listed in the staff report.
Commissioner Discussion:
Commissioner Rook: Confirmed adjacent properties would not lose access or utilities.
Planner Skluzacek: Correct, except for private utility relocation and easement dedication.
Commissioner Rook: Asked if those items were required.
Planner Skluzacek: Yes.
Commissioner Yurko: Asked if private sewer service was typical and whether it could connect
to City utilities.
Director McCabe: Public sewer/water are in the right-of-way; private lines serve individual lots.
Commissioner Schmokel: Asked if the tight corner and nearby house created issues, and
whether the split allowed fixing existing hardships.
Planner Skluzacek: Staff ensured no lot becomes less compliant; driveway setback was
preexisting but could be reviewed.
Director McCabe: New lots must meet City standards.
Commissioner Schmokel: Asked if the one-for-one land swap was for convenience.
Director McCabe: Owners negotiated the exchange; more options existed, but they sought to
keep land area the same on both parcels while relocating the driveway.
2
Commissioner Schmokel: Asked if adjacent owners agreed.
Planner Skluzacek: Yes; Highmark had begun the administrative subdivision paperwork.
Chair Fleming: Asked for expected home layout and size.
Planner Skluzacek: Only preliminary plans; final home must meet all City standards.
Chair Fleming: Asked for square footage.
Director McCabe: Estimated footprint ~9,800 sq ft.
Chair Fleming: Asked when renderings would be available.
Director McCabe: Renderings were not part of Commission review; only lot combination comes
to the Commission unless a variance is needed.
Chair Fleming: Asked to confirm that if any variances are requested that would be brought
back to the Commission.
Director McCabe: Confirmed.
Commissioner Yurko: Asked if any setback or impervious variances were needed.
Planner Skluzacek: No and any approval would be conditioned that no variances will be
requested as part of construction.
Applicant – Matt Eastman: (Highmark Builders) Said the goal was to create a clean parcel that
would be compliant for new home construction.
Chair Fleming: Asked for timeline.
Applicant Eastman: Construction hoped to begin in fall; approx. 18-month duration.
MOTION BY ROOK, SECONDED BY YURKO TO OPEN THE PUBLIC HEARING ON ITEM 4A
AT 6:18 P.M.
VOTE: Ayes by Fleming, Rook, Yurko, and Schmokel.
Motion carried 4-0.
Public Comment:
None.
MOTION BY SCHMOKEL, SECONDED BY ROOK TO CLOSE THE PUBLIC HEARING ON
ITEM 4A AT 6:19 P.M.
VOTE: Ayes by Fleming, Rook, Yurko, and Schmokel.
Motion carried 4-0.
Commissioner Comments:
Commissioner Schmokel: Supported the request and hoped they would not seek future
variances, noting this was the ideal time to correct any existing issues.
Chair Fleming: Agreed with Commissioner Schmokel’s comments and supported the
recommendation.
MOTION BY ROOK, SECONDED BY YURKO TO RECOMMEND CITY COUNCIL APPROVAL
OF THE COMBINED PRELIMINARY AND FINAL PLAT FOR HAUS ADDITION SUBJECT TO
THE CONDITIONS LISTED IN THE STAFF REPORT FOR THE JULY 6, 2026, PLANNING
COMMISSION MEETING.
VOTE: Ayes by Fleming, Rook, Yurko, and Schmokel.
Motion carried 4-0.
B. PDEV26-000018 – Tower Street SE – Land Use Map Amendment and Zoning Map
Amendment – Roers Acquisitions, LLC is requesting to amend the City of Prior Lake Future
Land Use Map to re-guide two (2) parcels from Retail/General Business to Urban High Density
Residential and to amend the City Zoning Map to rezone the parcels from C-2, General
Business to R-3, High Density Residential. The two parcels, which are located south of Tower
Street SE and west of a parcel addressed at 4540 Tower Street SE, do not have assigned
addresses. (PID’s: 252690030 & 252690041)
3
Director McCabe: Introduced the request for a Comprehensive Plan Land Use Map
Amendment and Zoning Map Amendment/Rezoning for property located west of 4540 Tower
Street SE. McCabe explained the history, physical site characteristics, and issues. He
commented on the property tax diversification, traffic, pedestrian safety, policies for amending to
the zoning map & land use map, permitted uses and compatibility.
Commissioner Discussion:
Chair Fleming: Asked how many residents or school-aged children could live in the proposed
166 units.
Director McCabe: Said the City had not analyzed this; applicant may have data.
Chair Fleming: Asked about active commercial/industrial projects.
Director McCabe: Said two to three were underway, mainly downtown.
Chair Fleming: Noted the City has 800+ acres of commercial/industrial land.
Director McCabe: Confirmed.
Chair Fleming: Asked why Prior Lake struggles with commercial/industrial growth.
Director McCabe: Cited limited transportation access and the City’s history as a bedroom
community.
Commissioner Schmokel: Asked what a C-2 commercial buildout would allow.
Planner Moretto: Said 60 ft building setback, 20 ft parking setback, and max height 45 ft/four
stories.
Commissioner Schmokel: Asked about the drainage easement.
Director McCabe: Utilities run through it; only parking could be placed there.
Commissioner Schmokel: Asked about potential for future commercial expansion.
Director McCabe: Said it is possible; school parcel could also be rezoned back to commercial if
needed.
Commissioner Schmokel: Asked about losing commercial to residential buffer transitions.
Director McCabe: Confirmed; some commercial uses require no public hearing.
Commissioner Yurko: Asked who owns the parcel west of the site.
Director McCabe: Said the City owns it; it is wetland and undevelopable.
Commissioner Yurko: Asked about wetland parcels between trucking and the subject site.
Director McCabe: Confirmed City ownership; stormwater flows into them.
Commissioner Yurko: Asked if mixed use was considered.
Director McCabe: Developer was not interested.
Chair Fleming: Asked if any developers have shown mixed-use interest.
Director McCabe: Not for this site.
Commissioner Yurko: Asked about splitting the building into multiple structures.
Director McCabe: Developer reduced height from previous concepts; no multi-building
concepts were submitted.
Commissioner Yurko: Asked why height was a concern adjacent to City-owned wetland.
Director McCabe: Slope would make a four-story building appear 55–57 ft tall on the west side
of the property.
Commissioner Yurko: Asked how many C-2 acres remain downtown.
Director McCabe: About two acres; redevelopment ongoing.
Commissioner Yurko: Asked the subject site acreage.
Director McCabe: About two acres.
Commissioner Rook: Asked maximum C-2 height.
Planner Moretto: 45 ft or four stories.
Commissioner Rook: Asked whether 1994 rezoning would have differed if high-density
housing was proposed.
Director McCabe: Unsure; rezoning to R-3 was discussed historically but not approved.
Commissioner Rook: Asked if adequate R-3 land exists elsewhere.
Director McCabe: No; City must plan additional acreage to meet Met Council requirements.
4
Commissioner Rook: Confirmed ITE traffic rates are based on 166 units.
Director McCabe: Correct.
Commissioner Rook: Asked if other R-3 areas abut R-1 this closely.
Director McCabe: A similar case existed at Jeffers Waterfront (~80 ft).
Commissioner Yurko: Estimated ~320 residents and ~61 peak-hour trips.
Director McCabe: Said full traffic study will occur at preliminary plat stage.
Commissioner Yurko: Asked for current apartment vacancy rates.
Director McCabe: Unsure; Scott County Maxfield Housing study to be released this fall; the
prior vacancy rate in the previous study was under 3%.
Chair Fleming: Asked what tools the Met Council uses if density requirements are unmet.
Director McCabe: They will not approve the comprehensive plan update until adequate
high-density acreage is shown.
Chair Fleming: Asked if Met Council is increasing scrutiny.
Director McCabe: Confirmed.
Applicant:
Nick Asta (Roers Companies): Explained Roers is a vertically integrated developer that builds
and manages its projects for the long-term. Said earlier concepts showed 60–75 units on the
east parcel by right with the west remaining commercial, but a single unified apartment project
would lessen overall traffic. Noted a 97-ft setback from homes (25-ft required) and building
elevations lower than the adjacent apartment, with buffering through green space, fencing, and
a retaining wall. Asta mentioned that an environmental review was underway. Said the property
has been for sale for about 5 years with little interest except multifamily; Roers reduced the
original concept of approximately 200-units for neighborhood compatibility. Mixed use was not
viable here due to location and demand. A two-building layout was studied but was found to be
inefficient. Market and traffic studies were also in progress.
Commissioner’s Questions:
Chair Fleming: Asked for unit price points.
Applicant Asta: Estimated $1500 (studio), $1750 (1-bed), $2300 (2-bed), $2700 (3-bed).
Chair Fleming: Asked why this specific site was selected.
Applicant Asta: Said Roers wanted to be in Prior Lake; other sites were fully commercial; no
available R-3 land; area had amenities and long-vacant commercial parcels.
Chair Fleming: Asked about expected demographics.
Applicant Asta: Mostly downsizing couples or younger couples; few school-age children in
similar buildings.
Chair Fleming: Asked whether Roers has incorporated neighborhood feedback.
Applicant Asta: Yes, lower height, increased setbacks, adjusted buffers, removed dog run, and
addressed traffic concerns.
Commissioner Rook: Asked where similar Roers projects existed.
Applicant Asta: Replied Shakopee, Lakeville, and Chanhassen.
Commissioner Rook: Asked for unit counts.
Applicant Asta: Chanhassen (125, 130, 180 units), Shakopee (200+), Lakeville (175–225).
Commissioner Rook: Asked about tax-base impact.
Applicant Asta: Rough estimate ~$4,000 per unit, which would vary by assessor.
Commissioner Yurko: Asked about the retaining wall and buffer maintenance.
Applicant Asta: Wall is 25 ft from property line; landscaping maintained; full-time maintenance
and snow removal would be provided.
Commissioner Yurko: Recommended coniferous plantings.
Applicant Asta: Said tree-line improvements were discussed with staff and Roers.
Commissioner Schmokel: Asked if the 25-ft buffer was part of the complex.
Applicant Asta: Yes.
Commissioner Schmokel: Noted renderings show mature trees; asked if screening relied on
5
neighbors’ trees.
Applicant Asta: Yes; project trees would take time to mature.
Commissioner Schmokel: Noted actual building corner is 97 ft from the property line.
Applicant Asta: Correct.
Commissioner Schmokel: Asked when Roers became interested in the property.
Applicant Asta: About one year ago; commercial parcels had been for sale for five years.
Commissioner Schmokel: Asked if interest arose because the district office became available.
Applicant Asta: Yes, also the combined parcels made the site feasible.
Commissioner Schmokel: Asked if Roers develops mixed-use elsewhere.
Applicant Asta: Yes, in Chanhassen and West St. Paul; noted mixed use succeeded mainly in
dense urban cores. This site was tucked into an existing residential area making it difficult to
support.
Commissioner Schmokel: Asked if Chanhassen had an urban feel.
Applicant Asta: Yes.
Commissioner Schmokel: Suggested that Prior Lake was trending similarly.
Applicant Asta: Possibly downtown, but not at this site.
Commissioner Schmokel: Asked whether the project would take Section 8.
Applicant Asta: No.
Director McCabe: Reviewed land-use map; remaining large commercial areas required future
infrastructure extensions; 2050 plan will shift some industrial to business park/general
commercial.
Chair Fleming: Asked if the city had until 2050 to implement.
Director McCabe: Yes, plan finalized by 2029 for years 2030–2050.
Chair Fleming: Asked if balancing residential and commercial would be difficult.
Director McCabe: Yes; City’s commercial/industrial share was low and will require intentional
planning.
Chair Fleming: Noted policy will guide decisions beyond just the Commission.
Director McCabe: Agreed.
MOTION BY ROOK, SECONDED BY YURKO TO OPEN THE PUBLIC HEARING ON ITEM 4B
AT 7:34 P.M.
VOTE: Ayes by Fleming, Rook, Yurko, and Schmokel.
Motion carried 4-0.
Public Comment:
James: (Toronto Ave.) Asked if the 1994 rezoning to R-3 created conditions for the current
proposal and if rezoning would have been approved knowing a future apartment could follow.
Director McCabe: Said the rezoning allowed school use, but parcels could always be reguided;
cannot speculate on 1994 decisions.
Mary Sheehan: (17306 Horizon Trl SE) Questioned ITE traffic estimates due to existing
congestion near Park Nicollet, Franklin Trail, Ponds Park, and the hill.
Chair Fleming: Asked staff to explain methodology used.
McCabe: Said numbers were standard peak-hour estimates; full traffic study will occur later.
Phyllis Broz: (4478 Pondview Trl) Felt the building was too large, too close to homes, and
moving too quickly; asked about alternatives and PUD acreage.
Chair Fleming: Asked staff to address acreage, height, and timing.
McCabe: PUDs normally need 10 acres, but exceptions are allowed; no approvals yet; Council
would need a supermajority.
Lori Nagel: (17126 Toronto Ave) Asked about realistic car counts and crime comparisons to
Shakopee.
Chair Fleming: Asked if she meant city-wide crime.
Nagel: Yes and asked for deeper study.
6
Steve Potter: (4498 Pondview Trl SE) Concerned about privacy and winter visibility; submitted
a petition with 100+ signatures opposing rezoning.
Alex Chea: (4466 Pondview Trl SE) Expressed concerns about traffic, infrastructure, building
scale, privacy, loss of commercial zoning, property values, and taxpayer impacts; urged denial.
Chair Fleming: Asked why cities evolve land uses.
McCabe: Said population growth and heavy low-density zoning created transition challenges;
past rezoning affected options today.
Jeff Parks: (4463 Pondview Trl SE) Preferred lower-density buffering; felt R-3 next to R-1 was
too intense without a street separation.
Robert Erickson: (4562 Pondview Trl SE) Concerned about sightlines, loss of commercial
opportunity, and incompatibility with long-term economic growth; said Jeffers Waterfront was not
comparable.
Chair Fleming: Thanked him; noted recessions and COVID affected development cycles.
Dean Neuman: (4623 Overlook Dr SE) Suggested medical/therapy uses might fit better;
building feels too large; urged preserving commercial acreage.
Mary Evenson: (17266 Toronto Ave) Concerned about variances and infrastructure impacts;
said commercial potential should be retained; preferred luxury apartments over lower options if
built.
Jenny Reimers: (4654 Oakwood Cir SE) Raised concerns about parking constraints during
softball events; asked that parking be included in future traffic studies.
MOTION BY ROOK, SECONDED BY SCHMOKEL TO CLOSE THE PUBLIC HEARING ON
ITEM 4B AT 8:13 P.M.
VOTE: Ayes by Fleming, Rook, Yurko, and Schmokel.
Motion carried 4-0.
Staff Responses from Comments and Questions:
Director McCabe: Thanked attendees and said park-event parking concerns are valid but
outside the developer’s traffic study and could be addressed at a future PUD review. Estimated
the nearby condo at 35–50 units. Noted the City has done only one other
commercial-to-residential rezoning in 15 years and was not broadly converting commercial land.
Said tax base effects were not part of Planning Commission or Council decisions, though an
apartment would likely generate more tax revenue than typical commercial uses (e.g., daycare,
funeral home, small senior care). Added that senior care had worked well as a buffer in other
areas, but demand at this site was unclear.
Commissioner Comments:
Commissioner Schmokel: Thanked the public and said she shared their passion. She was
concerned about losing town-center commercial land and believed doing so would limit long-
term potential for a more active, restaurant-supported community. Noted the 1994 rezoning
contributed to today’s challenges.
Commissioner Rook: Said he finds the rezoning difficult to support given the City’s need for
commercial land. Asked what happens to the existing high-density zoning if the request is
denied.
Director McCabe: Said the high-density zoning would remain unless changed later; converting
it back to commercial would require rezoning and a land-use amendment, which the Met
Council would likely oppose unless equivalent high-density acreage were added elsewhere.
Commissioner Yurko: Agreed with fellow commissioners; knows the area well and feels the
site had a future use, but not this project at this time.
Chair Fleming: Thanked staff and acknowledged the complexity. Said balanced growth was
critical and Met Council scrutiny was increasing. Appreciated the applicant’s revisions but
believed the timing and conditions were not right. Would not support advancing the proposal
and stressed the need for long-term, citywide planning discussions.
7
MOTION BY ROOK, SECONDED BY SCHMOKEL TO RECOMMEND THE CITY COUNCIL
DENY THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN LAND USE MAP AMENDMENT AND ZONING MAP
AMENDMENT/REZONING FOR THE SUBJECT PROEPRTY, SUBJECT TO THE LISTED
CONDITIONS ON THE JULY 6, 2026, STAFF REPORT.
VOTE: Ayes by Fleming, Rook, Yurko, and Schmokel.
Motion carried 4-0.
POINT OF ORDER AT 8:29 P.M.
Chair Fleming: Called a five-minute recess at 8:29 P.M.
Chari Fleming: Resumed meeting at 8:33 P.M.
5. Old Business:
A. PDEV26-000012 – 17031 Sunset Ave NW – Variance – The applicant, Ryan Bigot, is
requesting a variance to allow a 1.86% increase over the maximum 30% impervious surface
allowance to construct a new single-family home. This agenda item was tabled at the May 18th,
2026, Planning Commission meeting on a 5-0 vote until further reductions to the impervious
surface could be made by the applicant. (PID 254880030).
Planner Skluzacek: Informed the Commission that this agenda item request was tabled at the
May 18th, 2026, Planning Commission Meeting. The applicant was able to provide staff with an
extension request for an additional 60 days which allowed staff to revisit the request with the
applicant. Skluzacek said this variance was being brought back to the Planning Commission for
further consideration tonight with updates to the plan and survey provided by the applicant
including further impervious surface calculation reduction. Skluzacek gave staff’s conclusion to
adopt a resolution approving the variance from the impervious surface maximum to allow for a
new home on a property in the R-1 SD (Low Density Residential Shoreland) Zoning District
subject to the conditions listed in the staff report.
Commissioner Comments:
Chair Fleming: Asked for the originally proposed impervious surface.
Planner Skluzacek: Said it was 33.11% and has now been reduced to 31.86%.
Commissioner Schmokel: Asked if the footprint (1,849 sq ft) was considered for reduction.
Planner Skluzacek: Said no; applicant can address.
Commissioner Yurko: Asked if the 33% included the neighbor’s driveway encroachment.
Planner Skluzacek: Confirmed the 35 sq ft encroachment was proposed for removal and not
factored in the 33%.
Commissioner Yurko: Asked if the agreement with the neighbor was finalized.
Applicant Ryan Bigot: Yes; removal will occur during construction.
Commissioner Yurko: Asked about elevations, square footage, and stories.
Applicant Ryan Bigot: Replied that the proposed home is slab-on-grade, two stories; water
table prevents excavation.
Commissioner Yurko: Asked whether a third story was explored.
Applicant Ryan Bigot: Said they cannot create usable space within the 35-ft height limit.
Someone in the Audience: Noted maximum height allowed is 35 ft; plan was at 32 ft.
Commissioner Rook: Asked if proximity to the neighbor changed.
Planner Skluzacek: No; setback meets code, shifting would change dwelling-to-dwelling
separation.
Commissioner Yurko: Asked for height calculations.
Applicant Franek: Explained a third story would exceed height and reduce usable space; many
revisions were made to meet setbacks.
8
Commissioner Yurko: Asked whether the footprint was truly the only workable size.
Applicant Ryan Bigot: Said a third story would exceed height unless using a flat roof.
Chair Fleming: Asked for second-floor livable square footage.
Applicant Ryan Bigot: Said 1,658 sq ft; total livable area is 2,700 sq ft.
MOTION BY ROOK, SECONDED BY YURKO TO APPROVE THE RESOLUTION FOR A
VARIANCE REQUESTED FOR 17031 SUNSET AVE NW FROM THE IMPERVIOUS
SURFACE MAZIMUM TO ALLOW FOR A NEW HOME ON A PROPERTY IN THE R-1 SD
(LOW DENSITY RESIDENTIAL SHORELAND) ZONING DISTRICT SUBJECT TO THE LISTED
CONDITIONS.
VOTE: Ayes by Fleming, Rook, and Yurko. Nay by Schmokel.
Motion carried 3-1.
6. New Business:
None.
7. Announcements & Adjournment:
Fleming: Asked if there was a work session planned on June 20th.
McCabe: Confirmed and said it will replace the regular Planning Commission meeting and be
held in the Parkview conference room.
MOTION BY SCHMOKEL, SECONDED BY ROOK TO ADJOURN THE JULY 6, 2026,
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING AT 8:52 PM.
VOTE: Ayes by Fleming, Rook, Yurko, and Schmokel.
Motion carried 4-0.
Respectfully submitted,
Sandra Peppin, Development Services Assistant