The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutVA94-24 Collins Variance .~.. w.~':i OF PRIOR LAKE APPLICATION FOR VARIAOCE Applicant: 7;;;0 m ~ R (bCLI ^I S Home Phone: 1L/?- 39 7 ~ ~ Address: rl; (;;-'-/ T/J../GL/.A.bO!IJ A ~I-I-.. 012 S uJ. WOrk Phone: L/7Q-..307;J- ~Sb Property Owner: S/f,l!')cHome Phone: ~E /"j~cfv Address: -5>>111~ Work Phone: ~E ,;'33-1f3/ () Type of Ownership: Fee Contract Z Purchase Agreement X Q>nsultant/~Or: 'Phone: 7 :iES=~ ,~ . S;;I~G~ &/ Present Zoning: I - R.. ~ Leg Description """ I J JJ) of riance Site: C-/V~ Vari: ce Requested: I)t J cd:. VA 94-;<t..J PID# 25-UqC) -00'+-0 I Has the applicant previously sought to plat, rezone, obtain a\ Vjlriance or conditional use pemit on the subject site or any part of it? Yes';<' lob What was requested: When: Disposition: Desc~ibe the qpe of i.mgrovanents proposed: mE) tiE 1Ioos;r;., ~.() <6AP ACL Itt-.r;)....Q.N Tf5 ~JTe-HEJJ . J ~mISSION ~.LREMENl'S: ~ ~ Canpleted application fom. tBl iling fee. ~roperty SUrvey indicating the oposed developnent in re1ati n to property linFor ordinary-hig~water mark; proposed building elevations and drainage plan. CD rtified from abstract fim, names and addresses of property owners within 100 eet of the exterior boundaries of ~ ;r the subject property. (E)Canplete legal description & Property Identification Number-~~t/) (PID). (F)Deed restrictions or private covenants, if applicable. (G)A parcel map at 1"-20 '-50' showing: The site deve10pnent plan, buildings: parking, loading, access, surface drainage, landscaping and utility service. ONLY COMPLETE APPLICATIONS SHALL BE ALu:J:'J:w AND REVIEWED BY THE PLANNIN; <::cl>!MISSION. To the best of my knowledge the information presented on this fom is correct. In addition, I have read Section 7.6 of the Prior Lake Zoning rdinance w . ch pecifies requirements for variance procedures. I agree to p ide' jY:on 0 low the procedures as outlined in the Ordinance. ; \ ... Applicants sfrature SUbmitted this day of Fee Owners Signature THIS SPACE/IS ro BE FILLED OUT BY THE PLANNnX; DIRl:k:.LvR PLANNING ClBlISSION V APPROlED DENIED 7/21 ~ DATE OF HEARIN; ,....u.f COmcrL APPEAL APPROVED DENIED I' Dt\TE OF HEARING OONOITIONS: ~6 A1J7\ CJt6l) \~'1h.trJjjcl7l)~.1t550f)0Jk f~ 7/~/qq Signature of the Planning Director Date '.... ,~ ~ ../ DESCRIPTION: ~ii' Lot 4, Inguadona Beach on Prior lA.ke, Soott count.Y'~ M.1nn~s~~' and that part of Lot 5. of said plat described as tollows: Beginning at a point on the aoutherl1 Un. ot said Lot 5, distant 11.6 teet westerly of the southeast comer ot,aa.1d Lot 5; ~ence north parallel to the ( east line of adjoining Lot 4, extended. north a cl1stanoeof 2.2 teet; thence ( westerly to a point on the aoutherl$ line ot said Lot 5, distant 21 teet w,sterly of the southeast oomer of Mid Lot 5; thence easterly' along the s\utherly line of said Lot 5. to the point of be~inning. 4so showing all vielble improvements and enoroae~ents onto or off troll said property if any. ,- ;-<. ~7/.....,- ~~ ~~-- OClr/)- oOLf -- 0 SUBJECT SITE: _ l(o(P/4 1V)C\LActctt1YlCt et/Clek1 Or, ~w Tlmothv CiJII,~ / VARIANCE CHECK LIST "VARFM II APPLICANT: SCHEDULE HEARING DATE: DNR NOTICE IF SHORELAND: PREPARE AREA MAP: APPLICANT NOTICE: PROPERTY OWNERS NOTICE: NOTICE TO DOUG - ENGINEERING NOTIFY OTHERS: Scott County Watershed District COMMISSION~GENDA PACKETS: V / Staff Memo v Application Form iI Copy of Public Notice CHECK / V' i/ V. ~/ 7-II-qLf l> / \If MNDOT Other v:'. Applicable Maps v Copy of Parcel Info. ,/ Other Applicable Info. STAFF ACTIVITIES v IjA~Jqlf ~ . 7)~) qLf t I 7/1-.fJ-/01f I MAIL COpy OF APPLICATION AND REQUIRED CONDITIONS TO APPLICANT: V MAIL COPY OF APPLICATION AND CONDITIONS TO DNR: GIVE COpy OF APPLlCAITON AND CONDITIONS TO BLD. INSPECTOR ASSIGN FILE NUMBER: AMEND VARIANCE SUMMARY SHEET: ADD PERMIT TO PROPERTY MGMT: V' v v' 1 /')..;~JqLj -f/W-/qy , . FILE BY: File *: VA Q'/-2'/ Applicant ,11~(pIt.f r-~~ ~c." 9,J Legal: Lot L! 11f\~o.ctor"t bfacMddress: ~ _Tim 0+ h' . . t; 9il P, L. '" 'I'~ t rfr IrOr S FILE SHOULD CONTAIN: (tYIOvrrJV-- precv) ~ Staff Memo ...-- Applicable Maps and Documents / Original Application -- Copy of Public Notice /' Copy of Notice to OWners ~ _ Correspondence Planning Corom. Minutes Council Minutes if Applicable Other Information Cvuuu;,uts from the Cvulll~sioners were: future building plans, gutters and all were in support of the application. MaTIONBYLOFIUS, SECOND BY VONHOF, TO APPROVE THE FOlLOWING VARIANCES FOR LaI' 5, INGUAOONA BEAG!, 16604 INGUADONABEACH CIRa.E: 1. 5 FOOT FRONT YARD VARIANCE FROM TIlE 25 FOOT FRONT YARD SbltlACK REQUIREMENI 2. 2 FOOT SOUill SIDE YARD VARIANCE FROM THE 10 FOOT SIDE YARD SbltlACK REQUIREMENI 3. 5 FOOT NORTH SIDE YARD VARIANCE FROM THE 10 FOOT SIDE YARD SblJ:SACK REQUIREMENI 4. 28.5 FOOT LAKESHORE VARIANCE FROM THE 75 FOOT LAKESHORE :ScltlACK REQUIREMENI 5. A 1% IMPERVIOUS SURFACE VARIANCE FROM THE 30% I:N1ft..KYIOUS SURFACE MAXIMUM 6. A 1,200 SQUARE FOOT MINIMUM LaI' AREA VARIANCE FROM THE MINIMUM 7,500 FOOTLaI' AREA REQUIREMENT CONTINGENT UPON THE INSTAlLATION OF Gu 11 bRS, DESIGNING THE ROOF LINE TO CONIROL DRAINAGE. RATIONAL BEING TIllS IS A SUBSTANDARD LaI' OF RECORD, HARDSHIP IS CAUSED BY THE ZONING ORDINANCE AND NaI' THE ACTIONS OF THE APPLICANT, THE SUBJECf SITE WAS PLAllbU UNDER THE JURISDICTION OF A PREVIOUS GOVERNING BODY; AND IT WOULD NaI' BE Dt:..l KlMENTAL TO THE HEALTH AND WELFARE OF THE COMMUNITY Vote taken signified ayes by Loftus, Vonhof, Arnold, Kuykendall, and Roseth. MarrON CARRIED. {rEM VI - T1J\1OTHY COLLINS - VARlA~ Tunothy Collins, 16614 Inguadona Beach Circle, stated he is !-,w}Josing to remodel and add on to an existing family home. Construction of the addition will eliminate a water problem in the front of the house. Horst Graser, Director of Planning, presented the infOlmation as per the planning repOlt of July 21, 1994. The variances requested are as follows: (1) An 11.1 foot 1akeshore variance from the 75 foot lakeshore setback requirement (2) 7.4 foot north side yard variance from the 10 foot side yard setback requirement (3) A 7 foot south side yard variance from the 10 foot side yard setback requirement (4) A 4 foot east front yard variance from the 25 foot front yard setback requirement (5) A 4.4% illli^" v'ious sillface variance from the 30% illlp:..l v'ious surface maximlUTl. (6) A 670 square foot minimlUTllot area variance from the 7,500 square foot lot area requirement for a ripcnian lot The proposal is to add on and utilize the existing foundation. The lot is a substandard lot of record was platted under a previous government and the l-Ilvposed development is consistent with this neighborhood. Staff recommends the installation of gutters to control drainage. Comments from the DNR were discussed. Because of the uniqueness of the existing building being built over the adjacent prVi^'lLj line at the time of construction, the nOlth side ycn'd vcniance is reasonable, but Staff feels consideration should be given to a smaller south side ycn'd variance. Jen)' Halliday, 16604 Inguadona Beach Circle, stated that Mr. Collins would not be closer to the lake then what just approved for him and the adjacent lot to the south would always be vacant Bill Brastad, 16594 Inguadona Beach Circle, stated that Lots 2 and 3 (the adjacent lots to the south) were dedicated to the public but is used only by the Inguadona Beach neighborhood. Comments from the Commissioners were on: moving of house, substandard lot, difficult to rendit propelty, adjacent lot starns, roof lines, and precedent has been set PLANNING COMMISSION July 21, 1994 Page 5 MOTION BY LOFTUS, SECOND BY ROSElli, TO APPROVE FOR 16614 INGUADONA BEAG! CIRCLE LQCA1J:.lJ AT Lor 4 AND PIO Lor 5 INGUADONA BEACH, THE FOlLOWING VARIANCES: 1. AN 11.1 FOOT LAKESHORE VARIANCE FROM TIlE 75 FOOT LAKESHORE SJ:.ltlAO< REQUIREMENT 2. 7.4 Foor NORTH SIDE YARD VARIANCE FROM THE 10' SIDE YARD SJ:.ltlACK REQUIREMENT 3. A 7 FOOT soum SIDE YARD VARIANCE FROM THE 10' SIDE YARD SJ:.ltlACK REQUIREMENT 4. A 4 FOOT EAST FRONT YARD VARIANCE FROM THE 25' FRONT YARD SJ:.ltlACK REQUIREMENT 5. A 4.4% Th-'WJ:.Kv'lOUS SURFACE VARIANCE FROM TIlE 30% IMPREVIOUS SURFACE MAXIMUM 6. A 670 SQUARE FOOT MINIMUM Lor AREA VARIANCE FROM THE 7,500 SQUARE FOOT Lor AREA REQUIREMENT FORA RlPARIANLOI CONITNGENT UPON THE ROOF LINE DESIGN OR Gu n.J:.KS BE INSTALLED TO CON1ROL DRAINAGE. RA1l0NALBEING THE SUBJECf SITE IS A SUBSTANDARD Lor OF RECORD, THE ADJACENT LOT IS DEDICAlb1J TO BE VACANr, PREu:.lJENT HAS BEEN SET, SITE WAS PLAILtD UNDER THE JURISDICTION OF A PREVIOUS GOVERNMENT, AND WOULD Nor Dbl KlMENTALBE TO THE HEALlli AND WELFARE OF THE COMMUNITY Vote taken signified ayes by Loftus, Roseth, Arnold, Kuykendall, and Vonhof. MOTION CARRIED. OTIIER BUSINESS Bonnie Carlson, Assistant City Manager, gave a summary to consider the mcx:lification/c,ApaIlsion of the boundaries of Municipal Developu":'ut District No.2. The areas located in the district now are the southeast comer of the City, on both sides of County Road 21, the Waterfront Passage Business Park, and the indusnial area on the north side of County Road 21. The proposed areas to be included with Waterfront Passage Business Park are the properties on Walker, Pleasant and Main Street, and Highway 13 and 170th Street MOTION BY ROSElli, SECOND BY LOFfUS, TO APPROVE RESOLUTION 94-07PC lNTHATTHE PLAN FOR DEVELOPMENT DISTRICf NO. 2 MODIFICATION CONFORMS TO THE GENERAL PLAN FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MUNICIPAUfY AS A WHOLE AND TIlE COMrv1ISSION RECOMMENDS APPROVAL OF TIlE PLAN TO TIlE CITY COUNCIL. Vote taken signified ayes by Roseth, Loftus, Arnold, Kuykendall, and Vonhof. MOTION CARRIED. A directive was given to Staff to look into tree preservation policy and standards for private roads. MOTION BY Lut' 1 uS, SECOND BY KUYKENDALL, TO ADJOURN THE lvlJ::J:.lU-.ro. Vote taken signified ayes by Loftus, Kuykendall, AInold, Vonhof, and Roseth. MOTION CARRIED. The meeting adjourned at 11: 17 PM. Tapes of the meeting are on file at City Hall. Horst W. Graser Director of Planning Rita M. Schewe Recording Secretary PLANNING COMMISSION July 21.1994 Page 6 July 22, 1994 Timothy Collins 16614 Inguadona Beach Circle Prior Lake, MN 55372 Dear Mr. Collins, The following variances from Zoning Ordinance 83-6 were approved by the Prior Lake Planning Commission on July 21, 1994, subject to gutters or an appropriate roof line installed to mitigate the amount of drainage along the north and south sides of the proposed home. 1. An 11.1' lakeshore variance from the 75' lakeshore setback requirement. 2. 7.4' north side yard variance from the 10' side yard setback requirement. 3. A 7' south side yard variance from the 10' side yard setback requirement. 4. A 9.2' east front yard variance from the 25' front yard setback requirement. 5. A 4.4% impervious surface variance from the 30% maximum impervious surface requirement. 6. A 670 square foot minimum lot area variance from the 7,500 square foot lot area requirement. This variance will expire on July 21, 1995. If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me at 447-4230. Sincerely, Jiuw 'fr ,YKJj cNJJ Gina M. Mitchell f enc. cc. File 4629 Dakota St S.E., Prior Lake, Minnesota 55372-1714 / Ph. (612) 447-4230 / Fax (612) 447-4245 AN EQUAL OPPORTUNITY EMPLOYER "VA24PC' PLANNING REPORT AGENDA ITEM: SUBJECT: PRESENTER: PUBLIC HEARING DATE: #6 CONSIDER VARIANCE APPLICATION FOR TIMOTHY R. COLLINS HORST GRASER, DIRECTOR OF PLANNING _YES -X.NO JULY 21,1994 INTRODUCTION: The Planning Department has received a variance application from Timothy R. Collins who proposes to remodel and add on to an existing single family home as per attached survey. The subject site is located at 16614 Inguadona Beach Circle and is legally described as Lot 4, and Pia Lot 5, Inguadona Beach. The specific variances requested are as follows: 1. An 11.1' lakeshore variance from the 75' lakeshore setback requirement. (The proposed setback from the sU'ucture to the 904 contour is 63.9') 2. 7.4' n01th side yard variance from the 10' side yard setback requirement. (The proposed setback from the structure to the north property line is 2.6') 3. A 7' south side yard variance from the 10' side yard setback requirement. (The proposed setback from the structure to the south property line is 3') 4. A 4' east front yard variance from the 25' front yard setback requirement. (The proposed setback from the structure to the east front property line is 21') 5. A 4.4% impervious surface variance from the 30% maximum impelvious surface requirement. 6. A 670 square foot minimum lot area varIance from the 7,500 square foot lot area requirement. DISCUSSION: T~e lot is currently developed with a cabin built in 1962. The plat of Inguadona Beach was approved by the Scott County Board of Commissioners in 1924. The neighborhood was annexed to the City of Prior Lake in January, 1973. Inguadona Beach Circle is a private road that is not anticipated to be improved to a public street due to its substandard right-of-way, dedication to the private property owners within the plat and the fact that so much development exists at variance with Prior Lake zoning standards. 4629 Dakota St S.E., Prior Lake, Minnesota 55372-1714 / Ph. (612) 447-4230 / Fax (612) 447-4245 AN EQUAL OPPORTUNITY EMPLOYER The applicant proposes to remodel and add on to the eXIstmg home utilizing the eXIstmg foundation. See attached site plan for the proposed construction and attached survey for the existing cabin. The 4' front yard variance proposed will not encroach further to the east than the existing home which has a 15.8' setback. Twenty feet is the minimum length recommended by staff for a private driveway. The applicant has designed the proposed structure to provide for a 21' driveway which will allow for off-street parking of two vehicles. The lot is substandard in lot area consisting of 6,830 square feet, measured above the 904 contour. The majority of lots within the Inguadona Beach neighborhood are of similar size and area. The plat was originally intended for small cabins/resort type of development. There have been a considerable number of variances granted for new development in this area. However, a majority of the buildings were constructed prior to annexation and are at variance with Prior Lake zoning standards. The existing structure was actually built over the common property line of adjacent Lot 5 and neighboring property owner, Jerry Halliday was required to give approximately 2' of property at the southeast corner of the Lot 5, to this lot. The existing structure is setback only 1.3' from the north side property line and is not parallel with the lot line. The request is to extend the existing wall which would require a 7.4' north side yard variance. Staff is not opposed to this variance because it does not encroach closer to the side property line than the existing structure. The applicant requests an additional 7' south side yard variance in order to construct a garage large enough for two vehicles. The proposed garage size is approximately 22 x 22'. Although it is considered a hardship not to have a garage, the Planning Commission does not tend to grant beyond one, five foot side yard variance. Due to the legal non-conforming setback, (less than 2'), on the north side, the proposal already exceeds the typical variance granted for similar size lots. Staff is of the opinion that the applicant should consider a redesign to incorporate a garage and still maintain a 10' setback on the south side of the lot. The total amount of impervious surface proposed is 2,352 sq. ft. If all required setbacks are complied with, the resulting building envelope is 34 x 30 feet, about the size of a large, three stall garage. If the home were built on a sub-standard 7,500 square foot lot, the impervious surface coverage would equate to 31.3%. However, due to the fact that this lot of record is 6,830 square feet in area, the total proposed impervious surface is 34.4% and therefore a 4.4% variance has been requested. Please note, in the event that the south side yard variance is not granted, the amount of impervious surface will likely be substantially reduced. The requested 11.1' lakeshore variance is consistent with other variance requests on shallow lots within this subdivision. The variance is minimal and will allow the construction of a deck and porch addition on the lakeside of the home, similar to other lakeshore homes. ALTERNATIVES: 1. Approve the vanances as requested or with modifications directed by the Planning Commission. 2. Continue or table discussion of the application for specific reasons. 3. Deny the variance application in whole or in part based upon finding no hardship. RECOMMENDATION: The recommendation from staff is to approve the variances as requested with the exception of the 7' south side yard variance. It is the opinion of staff that a 10' south side yard setback should be required since the north side yard setback will be less than 2' from the closest part of the building to the lot line. The Planning Commission may consider the skewed position of the home and/or the existing legal non-conforming setback as additional hardship to grant additional variance to the south side property line. Staff recommends that specific hardship criteria be defined and that the maximum amount of variance be 5'. Granting of the variances should be subject to the condition that gutters or an appropriate roof line be installed to mitigate the amount of drainage along the north and south sides of the proposed home. * Please note the attached comments from the DNR related to the proposal. It is their recommendation there be no further encroachment toward the lakeshore than the existing foundation. In the event that the variance is granted, it is recommended that the new house/garage addition be redesigned in order to keep that portion of the living quarters/garage farther back from the shore, at least to a point parallel to the proposed deck. Staff is of the opinion that the 11.1' lakeshore variance is reasonable considering the multitude of existing legal and legal non-conforming structures within the neighborhood that are developed much closer to the lakeshore. Staff agrees that a redesign should be considered, but to eliminate or mitigate the need for a south side yard variance, which would also result in a reduction of impervious surface. Variance Hardship Standards: 1. Literal enforcement of the Ordinance would result in undue hardship with respect to the property. The building area once all required setbacks are applied, is not adequate to build a single family home. Other similar size and shaped lots are developed with single family homes and/or have been granted variances to permit construction. Literal enforcement of the Ordinance would result in undue hardship to the property. 2. Such unnecessary hardship results because of circumstances unique to the property. The property was platted under the jurisdiction of Spring Lake Township which allowed the subdivision of the lot and subsequent development of the existing cabin. The legal non-conforming lot size and area is unique with respect to the subject site. 3. The hardship is caused by provisions of the Ordinance and is not the result of actions of persons presently having an interest in the property. The hardship is caused by adoption and application of the Prior Lake Zoning Ordinance to a property which was platted and developed under the jurisdiction of Spring Lake Township. 4. The variance observes the spirit and intent of this Ordinance, produces substantial justice and is not contrary to the public interest. The variances recommended by staff observe the spirit and intent of the Zoning Ordinance and are consistent with development patterns and other variances granted within the Inguadona Beach neighborhood. As such, the variances recommended are not contrary to the public interest. J' SURVEY PREPARED FOR: TIMOTHY E. COLLI NS 16614 INGUADONA BEACH PRIOR lAKE. MH. 55372 Valley Surveying Co., P.A. SUITE 120-C. 16670 FRANKLIN TRAIL FRANKLIN TRAIL OFFICE CONDOMINIUM PRIOR lAKE, MINNESOTA 55372 TELEPHONE (61 Z) 447 - Z570 PRIOR LAKE EL. 903.2 ~I 26/93 ........ I /~/ ,.,t"L 0/ ..," ~ .. J.j ~"., '\0' \\f;>~~ '!. I +-",: It~Z. I~' , ..~. .; ~ 4'" . \ - .~ .lOt' , LOr- I .l-- ~ ~ !i : ~13'a: ~~Q1~ ~i)! ~ ~51=' ~. ~ " (r) 0 ~ I ~ ~ ~~ ...... DESCRIPTIONl "'- '- Lot 4, Inguadona Beach on Prior Lake, Scott COWlty, Minnesota and 1:I1at part: ot Lot 5, of said plat deecribed as followSl Beginning at a point on the southerly line of said Lot 5, distant 11.6 feet westerly of the southeast oomer of said Lot 51 thencs north parallel to the east line of adjoining Lot 4, extended north a distanoe of 2.2 feet I thenoe westerly to a point on the southerly line of said Lot 5, distant 27 feet westerly of the southeast oorner of Hid Lot 51 thenoe easter17 along the souther17 line of said Lot 5, to the point of beginning. . Also showing all visible improvements and enoroaohments onto or oft from said property if any. NOTES' Benchmark ElevatiOn! 927.96 walkout elevation of the existing house on the property. 927.5 Denotes existing grade elevation l( Denotes proposed finished grade elevations Denotes proposed direotion of finished drainage Net Lot Area = 5,592 Ilquare feet o I SCALE 30 60 I Dell. L1cent, HIJ. /0183 IN FEET o Den"'.. 112 Inch . Hinch Iron /IlOllumenl ,.1 lIIld .-ted by lice... Ho. /0183 . ~ot.1 I,,," mMtumenf found . Denof.. P. ,<. Noll I.t FILE No. TITT lOOk ". """E 55 .9o~ --I '" -- .:~-..... . - '- :::::::: ~--... .......... -..... '....... "--" I: , " (" i IIEl,\, I ~..-..l -' --.:...:... " , , :-- <+. . ':,., ... ;:. . J, f' " ; ,_:~o " ! ~ \'.>\S' : t(e:.'( i: -----~ --1 :- _...... .... -_0. E:.)(I~T 1 rJc;. 1"oUtJDAilON ~)(I~Tl~&. ~ r:.: !.:...;,~:~. .' .'r.""," " , I .~'<~ DJl'\I~A'J - .8.\/ '. \~ : ri:(.~ 01Te. ~1.4: P~. A.. l , .:.,' I'J J',\-, '\11 ""'\0', ..-, '.ED , NoPm-l ) f'" "'-I "I///Ld I II lilt 'f'oIZTlOtJ OF' E?x1~/~ HOLl$~ ~ L-OC-....T~D N\JW' ~U$/C:A.AfZ~6'" i~~t',~t:1 iftMcJ'l Ii 1f1,-.......~ l~\..:!r::~ .... ~,"4 ..k!...... !,' PHONE NO. .~ [J:{) I]! ~ @'ITffi:I ~lRDES~:T;T:ENT OF NATURAL METRO WATERS - 1200 Warner Road, st. 772-7910 RESOURCES Paul, MN. 55106 FILE NO. July 13, 1994 Mr. Horst Graser City of Prior Lake 4629 Dakota Street S.E. Prior Lake, Minnesota 55372 RE: VARIANCE REQUEST, 16614 INGUADONA BEACH CIRCLE, LOT 4 & P/O LOT 5, INGUADONA BEACH, PRIOR LAKE, SCOTT COUNTY Dear Mr. Graser: I have hearing Circle. for the reviewed the materials which accompanied the notice of for variance at Lot 4 and plo Lot 5, 16614 Inguadona Beach Please incorporate these comments into the hearing record proposed variance. The Department of Natural Resources is not opposed to a variance provided the original foundation size is not increased waterward of the existing structure. It appears from the information provided that the proposed construction will result in both a deck and some portion of the living quarters encroaching lakeward of the existing structure. If the proposed addition north of the proposed deck is "squared off", the setback variance can be further reduced. Bear in mind, the applicant is required to provide evidence of hardship when pursuing a variance from zoning standards. If the city chooses to grant the variance, it is recommended that as a requirement of the variance, the new house/garage addition be redesigned in order to keep that portion of the living quarters/garage described above farther back from the shore, at least to a point parallel to the proposed deck. Please send me a copy of the minutes of the variance proceedings following Planning Commission and city Council action on the matter. I am interested in reviewing Planning Commission and City Council discussions regarding issues related to the variance process. Thank you for the opportunity to review and comment. Please call me at 772-7910, if you have questions. Ncer. ely , VJJ-~ ~-~~ Patrick J. L~h . Area Hydrologist AN EQUAL OPPORTUNITY EMPLOYER "VA24PN" NOTICE OF HEARING FOR VARIANCE You are hereby notified that the Prior Lake Planning Commission will hold a hearing in the City Council Chambers located at City Hall, 4629 Dakota Street S.E. on: Thursday, July 21, 1994 at 9:45 p.m. APPLICANT: SUBJECT SITE: REQUEST: Timothy R. Collins 16614 Inguadona Beach Circle Lot 4 and P/O Lot 5, Inguadona Beach The applicant proposes to remove part of the existing home, utilize the existing foundation and construct an addition as proposed on the attached survey reduction. The applicant requests that the Planning Commission grant the following variances in order to build the structure as proposed: L An 11.1' 1akeshore variance from the 75' 1akeshore setback requirement. (The proposed setback from the structure to the 904 contour is 63.9') 2. 7.4' north side yard variance from the 10' side yard setback requirement. (The proposed setback from the structure to the north property line is 2.6') 3. A 7' south side yard variance from the 10' side yard setback requirement. (The proposed setback from the structure to the south property line is 3 ') A ~ east front yard variance from the 25' front yard setback requirement. (The proposed setback from the structure to the east front property line is 15.8 ') 4. 5. A 4.4% impervious surface variance from the 30% maximum impervious surface requirement. 6. A 670 square foot minimum lot area variance from the 7,500 square foot lot area requirement. If you are interested in this issue, you should attend the hearing. The Planning Commission will accept oral andlor written comments. Questions related to this hearing should be directed to the Prior Lake Planning Department by calling 447-4230 between the hours of 8:00 a.m. and 4:30 p.m. Monday through Friday. Prior Lake Planning Commission Date Mailed:July 11.1994 4629 Dakota St S.E., Prior Lake, Minnesota 55372-1714 / Ph. (612) 447-4230 / Fax (612) 447-4245 AN EQUAL OPPORTUNITY EMPLOYER ~ l( Vn-~'-ImL Ij NEW ABSTRACTS CONTINUATIONS CLOSING SERVICE REG<5TERED PROPERTY ABSTRACTS TITLE INSURANCE RECORDING SERVICE SCOTT COUNTY ABSTRACT AND TITLE, INC. 223 HOLMES STREET. P.O. BOX 300 SHAKOPEE. M'iNESOTA 55379 David Moonen and Dale Kutter Kerry Meagher. General Counsel TELEPHONE: (612)445-6246 FAX: (612) 445-0229 June 17, 1994 Tim Collins 16614 Inguadona Beach Circle Prior Lake, MN 55372 To Whom it may ::mcern: According to tt2 1994 tax records in the Scott Cou~cy Treasurer's office, the following persc:.s are listed as the owners of the :noperty which lies within 100 feet of the following described property: Lot Four (4), =::lguadona Beach, according to the pl2.t thereof on file and of record in the C:fice of the Register of Deeds in and for said county and state. A1~D That part of Vt 5, Inguadona Beach, described as follows: Commencing at a point on the SDtherly line of said Lot 5, distant 11.6 feet Westerly of the Southeast corne: of said Lot 5; thence North pardlel to the East line of adj oining Lot L extended North a distance of 2.2 ieet; thence Westerly to a point on the S:utherly line of said Lot 5 distan: 27 feet Westerly of the Southeast corne: of said Lot 5; thence Easterly alon~ the Southerly line of Lot 5 to the point c: beginning, according to the plat th2reof on file and of record in the Office of the Register of Deeds in and for Sco:t County, Minnesota. CITY OF PRIOR L~~E CITY ADMINISTRATJR 4629 DAKOTA ST S~ PRIOR LAKE MN 55372 JERRY & NiGELA HALLIDAY 16604 ING':'ADONA BEACH CIRCLE PRIOR LAK~ MN 55372 WILLIAM A BRASTP~ & WIFE 4808 11TH AVE SC MPLS MN 55417 DONALD RA.~BAIN 16615 INGrADONA BEACH CIRCLE PRIOR LAK~ MN 55372 CHERYL A GARNER 16595 INGUADONA ~EACH CR S PRIOR LAKE MN 55372 /\ -{;' (J ~iL. , .Lf/~/lr, , David E. Eoonen President "\ MARGARET A RAHBA=N 16615 INGUADONA ~EACH SW PRIOR LAKE MN 55372 LAND FORD ADLER POBOX 411 PRIOR LAKE MN 55372 .. ,~...;;'.;;:.C:.::"'-==-(...;;. ':":;~I.S.~~f;.,.ro ~. ,<~' .',"'.ir''''')'....~ ......;- ~,' ,. . ~" SCOTT COUNT'( ABSTRACT ~ , . .'~ _ _ AND 1l11f, 1Ne. ~ o. '. lJcens8flAbstrar:tor I ,...... State GfMlnnesota ~ MEMBER MINNESOTA LAND TITLE gcf8H,;~'- ?..- ~,';- ,- ,-;';- ,....... -~ -..t AGENT FOR CHICAGO TITLE INSURANCE COMPANY I" Iii ... , I II Ii ! i .. I T1 ...v\ c.o~, I>.J S ' I' (., " 'v -;J:.f.J ~()A 'PovA 'b tE~~ II p~-'01\.. ~\al} ~t.J. 55'31'2. II I 111~.po ~I'V\ VA,~ son.v.ey <::0. ~ A. s- l\-q ~ t# 7~7 II'! ~!:T" t..aT 4tUCAQ -=- 5 S-, L... 5.~ I . 'I ~ ~t..e- 30 % Co\J~ ~ )( 5'S-, 'L S r ~ J (,7 7. G. S.+:, ~ AtL4t4 lWC,-uO,w(. fttowt 'fc.,~ -/.0 l~4G<.. = (,830 S.~ ,. i!A~Ov\JAA1~ '";0 % Co~~"- "I bB ~ S.{: ~ ~ ()Cf1 Ii II ~S""/AJC: Cov~ttAQGS I, II ~'frs"1"1V? I U "..s ,~ ~~ ~I I( /JJcJSG. /0 z. ~ SA: $'-46 "2. & IS.+: ... StOIkV~"S LCfi. S.t. P~A17. 5'1 S S.~. Wt::Jo(') S'4-e.ps l ~ If ~.~. K rt.l!",dt~ lN~ /1.. 5' . S.~ 1. ';C,f~. Sr. , 1\. -, ;', lJ L -...,J L'6 I t.c 51 :~ IA '" I ::;; r cr ~ ~ (/) -:;J~. (; I I . I iPC\o t oS ""'" Co~ ~ ~ ! ~ou ~e. I i ~~t!:> I \ I ~l\?~I.~ Ffl.ON'T )1-00'( . i J> fl (l) II c.u~ I? O!. S",...~ -E,c jSi U/OOf) Ll '" *f~ ~'Cr4' AJI ~ IC,S8.~ -ZSZ.o (P8. " ( <t .0 J{lf t.?) ;".0 / ~ tf .0 I Z:~ .00 .::=...--- '--- 2. 7S3JZ-S S.(' I G.S '3. t; 'l C.") , () C^ .I'. r/. , I -1') ~. !, ~ 2S~ ...:.. I '.;<:)('\- V -0 <C- I \.9 (),j') - 2 L I LI'( J . " .,' , , i ~.. ".:' i . j :1 ;1 !'~cJ~ PM..~rJ1'~f _ i I '1:e.~ isr. ~<.J~~ Z"3~~ 7- $"" z... -= I !~VO\lCQ ~ '2.153. -;. 5"5''f 1.. ., ,II il Ii ~",f~i. C4uCAUJ"E 'Z. ~<fS"' ..;. (,1";0 -:I I ~ I' lot ll?rtof~~1M? 1, 7~ -t 'v-;o -0: Ii Ii 1/ II I 1 ! I I i I I I I " ,I I i I I i, II :, !I Ii H ., li Ii II " 11 II il II I ~ Ii d I' .. ::l 1:1 i,![. " !ll ii iI iI !! " p~ z.. 41. ,. ~o L/'I. 2. ~ % 3t./. 3 ~ ~4 40.3 :% PRIOR LAKE EL. 903.2 .4/ 26/93 ..I. +. ... :.. ~ . t ~ 0.' ~. r:::~-- . ~~-.--, u \ l'!l J ~., 'f... 1t. ~ \ t 1 '" r. · \ ~' '\ " ...., ~ ~ "- ---- <i S-o S.f., --------= , ).1" <; ~ (J/IU.. - // // -~- VA-RI AI0C-r:;'S kEQUb"S, 1St:, ,JtJRTH 81 D~ @ FfuIY\ d-' To 1 f 3" ON C)(/3 TIN<S r::ov...NO ATlON WCST S I b~ ~ @ FeoIY\ r? ( to II To [; I ~ 71 G, II TO pf2 c>Pc=R..T~ L, N~ 03 ' 9 I{ 70 9DL( LffJ<6 ELEU Wit ) c-~ 1-ltV~ 90CLTH SIDiS @ OF .3 I Ff.) J2... / 1-/6 Le;;v ~7k1 THE g\L) L....DJ AlCS EftS T .s) DE:' @ c7-I' 3" TO cPr? ' to 'I ~ _17' Co" TO /S' a" oiU cx~/ vAle; h:JUNJ)I1-TlCV1J '; / ". \ -. pc.: \ " ~.~ P' t )1\ .: . I I ,*J ~ I ~~ ,.' ':; '~~ ...........-:::::::--. ~:........_- ----.- -' '~~~<:~-;I!---'~::~~ ~ '- ~~- :(~~ .........-- ... ~-~- ~ I :.:.": ~ 0: ~r . I', /. ,-_..DL ~A~Vii~~",'~'" .',......; i ' \II '^I ; '\. . ! J ! I ". .. , ,i I ,. ,'./ .~. ,.' t I~ " //' ! . I ; I : : ,,/ . // ~. .' ,:' '. " " ., -. ..... I. ::'" " . '\ \ ). ", ", ," '... "...... '-....~ ~-" 'y'" ... I"" .... \ .J :Jt.5 "~i '" " ":', ", I I' Do:'ve-w.1 I " I I I J I ,--~ --~- .., -::Ih\ t<-ey e.,,(I'.TI"'~ Fou&J~T'ON .f'\. "'" ~)(I"TiN'" ~ I///d ~'olJ Of' Itll,q',...v.. HOuo.e I'e.l..c%o"TeD U 11111. ~ ~/C1AfZ~6 01T~ ~1.4: @ /oJOP-1H PL- A..I'J /"-1/1 \ \ D(Z'''~~J .8.1'. ~ ", :.'~ . ~., . :.. j.,~,~;; '~i " :"',: ) :~:.'}'~~ ":;~~l:itt:.~,: \(,;,~:.r~;~{iI:<';,'~', :(..: ~.;~'''~;'~ ;~7.''''':llt~~.p;.,~1: ''-;; ." .'t'tJlPo~t"~'~";~( ',' . ~l ~'. .,". :,..:,I\.'''.l.l:!~.. t" ':-' ': >ro, . .....' 'il :"r":.\""-' . . " .. ...,~, "'j .,J .,{ :" " "F \,f ).;' ,.... . , I. . <'"I " I \ a. ~ J I -J E>' .;' '. ,r,. ............. --~ ~~~ ::0-----""" ....-- ~ ----::...--- ~-~. -- ~~. .... ~"..: ..---: -:::::>- . ,~..~~ --.. ~~, . . -...~-= NGW Dl!Ii"t'- ..,.. ~ -:'- j,.; . '~. I ,.. I;. '. j.' , .. .';i ,:.it f' ~, ~ ~,~ I.. ,. >; l ~,. };~ ; ~ ~. ',\\( f: ~ " :- ,,"-,. ., . ~t: . ~. : ., f . .. .,' , 'i,l. :1, -..- ...-- I , ,. ,.. . l..., \1, -... I: : ,~ ( -~.... i ,"'. 'j . ,I ,~: I~ I,; . ..~... J, .,' ~'~\ ".;.i. .' ~~O , rY . eo -+--~ . ~: 'j ,. \,i~ , :t<.ey '. "'.: ~ ~ . " A-....... . .. ,... .' .j ~, ,\ . -_'-..~,.....__.. ~. .J e.)(I4bT I tJC\t=:olJ""~i'oN ~ - -f' '" "" I ~)(L~TIN~ f+ot,J?e. - . ~ 'lio ---- ,\ ///~ ."fbf'TJOtJ OF ~1~1~ "J. : HOU$~. ~ J...Oc........,..~D . N~vJ. HOU$/64.Af2:A:4\6\ '..~~ .,... .: .;, .. ) : , . ~'. , i' . ..... ~.. ~:~~;';\ . , ,".: ,...- ~. ',,;. ;0' }-; . ~;'j;j1~ft..}{~~~ ~;o. '.3."'.?'1l:Sltif.' i;.t.~~' ,~ .~~ "f.~)\\A:):",l' ",:.:, I ~ ~":~i.)'~rr:~ .' ....~..;J:~ A'}'I~.~;~ ' ~~~.\:t~, .~., . . ,..}i!+~N!J .~\4~~ . ',',- Pt-.~ ~ K.J . . . ", t1 ~ ;..':\ cl', .:,.>.-.,....:~ ; IW . lJoPm1. ) ;;.illLl. . -,t," f. " 6JTB ,.j"~. " .~ \ ".' .1.' ,.' '" h.?<'. :: , ,~.;~~f.:-~,.'~~'~ 'J' ~,~} '1-' :, - ,""" ~.: t,:: ,..". "}, ., , " L'-,;' ;'01 SURVEY PREPARED FOR: TIMOTHY E. COLLINS 16614 INGUADONA BEACH PRIOR LAKE, MN. 55312 Valley Surveying Co., F?A. SUITE 120-C, 16670 FRANKLIN TRAIL FRANKLIN TRAIL OFFICE CONDOMINIUM PRIOR LAKE, MINNESOTA 55372 TELEPHONE (6/2) 447-2570 -... .....; I /~I +~L f .,.,b ~ olt)fJ if ..f. ~., 'I. ",,~~ ! !~.. ~~.~~Z4j': I~ ...~. , /~ , ",. '/1- - ctt " ~ - .. I .... . CII' tor 5 -;~ o o;r ~~!ll[ ~ ~ ar ~'Jt: ~...- If . QiI) -' -"'l.' . Q, ).:. ~8 a, .l I fl)Q!u , ;i; I ! S ~7 ..... PRIOR LAKE EL. 903.2 M 26/93 / / 1!1(I$T1NG HOUse DESCRIPTION: Lot 4, Inguadona Beach on Prior Lake, Scott County, Minnesota and tha't part of Lot 5, of said plat described as follows: ~ Beginning at a point on the southerly line of said Lot 5, distant 11.6 teet westerly of the southeast corner of said Lot 5; thence north parallel to the east line of adjoining Lot 4, extended north a distance of 2.2 feet; thence westerly to a point on the southerly line of said Lot 5, distant 27 feet westerly of the southeast corner of said Lot 5; thenoe easterl1 along the souther l.Y line of said Lot 5, to the point of beginning. ' Also showing all visible improvements and encroachments onto 01" oft 1......,... said property if any. NOTES' Benchmark Elevation: 927.96 walkout elevation of the ex1st.tng hoUlNl on the property. Denotes proposed finished grade elevations ..~ 927.5 Denotes existing grade elevation )( Denotes proposed direction of finished drainage Net Lot Area = 5,592 square feet o , SCALE 30 I IN 60 1 I here! by me ~om Ia 0 Dote .,,~~ FE.ET o Denot.. 1/2 Irtdt " 14 inch iron monument 'M and mcried by LicetIM No. 10/83 . Denote. iron monument found ~ Denote. P. K. Nail set LlotrIh NO. 10'18' FILE No. 1811' 800f( "4 ;Ak 55